ASRock X370 Gaming K4 ATX Motherboard Review

Test Results And Final Analysis

Synthetics & Apps

DiskSPD makes its way back into the lineup since our Toshiba RD400 is installed snugly back into its M.2 port. The ASRock X370 Gaming K4 enjoys a 25 MB/s increase over the X370 Taichi in both random 4k read and write tests. Cinebench results are also in the Gaming K4’s favor with single threaded performance.

However, the Taichi sample we reviewed previously comes ahead in the remaining synthetic benchmarks, although the wins are usually within three percentage points. Looking into the Adobe delta within the PCMark chart, the entire suite is running within two percentage points of the Taichi until Adobe Illustrator comes along. Although a second and a half isn’t a long time, that result tarnishes what would have been a pretty neck-and-neck comparison.

The remaining application tests are rather dull, with both boards taking shots at the other with minor differences. In the larger scheme of things, the performance data is definitive: both products are within two percentage points of each other with the slight lead going to the ASRock X370 Gaming K4.

3DMark & Games

Although 3DMark and Metro Last Light Redux enjoy the extra horse power of a second GPU, the remaining three titles either didn’t support it or required some tinkering and tuning to get running properly. We're disappointed that we cannot provide SLI data in this review.

With The Talos Principle, playable framerates are achievable using our dated GTX 970, all the way to 4k resolution and Ultra settings. By bumping up the resolution alone, average framerates only fall by around 15 FPS across the test samples. Comparing the two boards, a 3% win goes to the Taichi at 1080p, but at 4K it's a virtual tie.

F1 2015 also shows promise for those who want 4K in a surround monitor configuration, even with older GPU hardware. Minimum frames hover right above 30 FPS for both samples, and the ASRock X370 Taichi takes the prize at higher resolutions. The Gaming K4 does squeak out almost 2 FPS more at 1080p for an impressive 0.20% lead.

We've got mixed feelings about Metro Last Light Redux. With a 144Hz gaming monitor, 1080p would be suitable on either platform, with only minor instances of either minimum or maximum framerates occurring. Our pseudo 4K setup also delivers a pleasurable experience at High settings with the occasional slow downs within the benchmark.  However, throwing in Very High settings shows many sections of the routine in the sub 30 FPS regions.

Our resident CPU bound game, Ashes of the Singularity, strikes with a vengeance on this Ryzen 1700X. At 1080p, as the batch complexity increases, the gap between the Taichi and the Gaming K4 increases, in favor of the Taichi. 4K and High settings could be playable since RTS games don’t necessarily require high frame rates, but that Crazy setting . . . ouch. The ASRock Gaming K4 takes the lead by a few frames here, but 25 FPS is as painful as nails on a chalk board. (Editor's Note: These tests were run prior to recent game updates.)

Overall, both boards perform similarly at both resolutions, but the ASRock Gaming K4 trails by 1.4%.

Power, Thermals & Overclocking

After idling for about 10 minutes, both systems show a respectable 69W of power draw, and temperatures are running cool at 28°C (CPU) and 48°C (CPU Diode1). Given the discovery of the temperature delta between tCTL and Tj, we’ll continue to report unadjusted CPU Diode1 values for this 1700X sample.

Bumping up to full CPU load with Prime95, the temperature delta between tCTL and Tj increases to 24°C, while staying a toasty 48°C above ambient temperatures. Regulator temperatures are staying reasonably close as well, and both samples hover within 5W of each other.

GPU stress is consistent after letting the system settle for a bit, but when running both Prime95 and FurMark in parallel, it was difficult to get a consistent reading. Values reported are the maximum observed while the applications ran, though any fluctuation in the result is primarily driven by the GPU utilization at any given time. It's interesting to note that power measurements for full system load are more stable at the 3460x1920 Surround resolution since the GPU was given more priority to keep the fuzzy donut spinning.

Right out of the gate, increasing the CPU multiplier to 38 successfully engages all CPU cores at the advertised Turbo threshold. Rather than swing for the fences, increasing the multiplier to 39 got us to a stable OS, but any mention of Prime95 to our microphone shuts the system down. Adjusting the loadline to level 3, Prime95 loads and runs for about six minutes, which is an improvement over the results we saw with the X370 Taichi.

Using Fixed Voltage mode within the UEFI, we increase the core voltage to 1.375V and it successfully runs for 30 minutes within Prime95. With regulators still running rather cool at 22°C over ambient, we are compelled to jump to 4GHz! With some luck, the stress test loads and promptly fails. Bumping up to our voltage ceiling of 1.3875V, it runs for about 10 minutes again, and then the black screen shows its face.

Stability is within our grasp so decreasing the multiplier to 3950MHz gains a few more minutes of stability and warm exhaust for our toes. One more click down on the clock multiplier and we can successfully run Prime95 for 1.5 hours. However, this baby is cooking now at 64°C Tj and a whopping 96°C tCTL.

At the end of the night, our system had run for 12+ hours of 3850MHz at 1.3875V while using the Level 3 loadline setting. We netted 50MHz over the Taichi system, but at the cost of some pretty high temps. The Noctua NH-D15 SE-AM4 did a sufficient job, but any more voltage and we'll require water cooling.

We did receive some DDR4-3200MHz memory in time for this review, but man, I hate memory overclocking! Upon installing this memory we couldn't get the board to boot at DDR4-2666. Pulling up the Memory QVL sheet shows that this specific set is not on the approved list. After a lengthy discussion with ASRock, it turns out that this four-layer board has some difficulty with DRAMs produced by SK hynix. After tinkering with tCL, re-flashing UEFIs, and trying reduced configurations, we threw in the towel. We’ll have to debug this in our next review.

Ironically, the DIMMs we used from the previous article booted up at DDR4-2666MHz just fine. We have another set of DIMMs en route to properly overclock both ASRock boards, so keep your eyes peeled; we'll revisit the ASRock X370 Gaming K4 and X370 Taichi.

Performance, Value & Summary

Comparing two higher end boards from the same vendor can be pretty boring. Given the target markets for both products, the result twists are sure to spark some discussion. Both motherboards are so close in performance that measurement noise is probably the top reason for variance.

We were hoping to see an efficiency difference in these two boards, but even with the different regulator designs, both products are within 1% of each other.

Factoring in non-sale pricing at the time of this writing, it’s hard to beat the $50 advantage of the ASRock Gaming K4.

But, there’s a catch. Remember how we mentioned giving users options in the X370 Taichi review? The E key WiFi port is what truly separates these products. If we were to deploy this Gaming K4 board in a wireless scenario, we’d have to spend upwards of $40 to get a WiFi card and however much it costs to route and add antennae. The second M.2 SSD connector's PCIe 2.0 x2 interface is another consideration: The Taichi provides two x4 M.2 interfaces out of the box.

But the X370 Gaming K4 is all about gaming, and that’s what it’s best suited for. Save that extra $50 for a capture card, or a mechanical keyboard, or send it to your fellow AMD fanboy for a new GPU for his AMD Ryzen reviews! I kid, I kid.

Pending our DDR4 overclocking refresh, we'll tentatively assign the Gaming K4 Tom's Hardware's Approved award.

MORE: Best Motherboards

MORE: How To Choose A Motherboard

MORE: All Motherboard Content

This thread is closed for comments
20 comments
    Your comment
  • Crashman
    Very nice, thanks Terk!
  • elbert
    Great review and the only question I have is on the temperature. Does those temps take into account AMD's reported 20c offset for the 1700x and 1800x? Only the 1700 was reporting correct temps a few weeks ago.

    Update: I see were the 20 offset was added in my second look over the review.
  • Midnitte
    Now if only the Tachi would ever go in stock...
  • Thelatestnewbgamer
    why is confirmed G.Skill memory being used. it easily hit's 3200mhz on the tai-chi board. i'm pretty sure this same stick of ram which is a samsung dimm and the Preferred memory manufacture of choice to use when building a high end ryzen system would run 3200mhz in this gaming k4 board,,,this ram was pulled outta my kaby lake i5 system...thanks for the review glad you mentioned the issue with ram compatibility and the generic speed the average user will get if using incompatible memory i imagine the scores would be awesome if you were able to hit 3200mhz @ 14-14-14-34
  • theterk
    An in-depth review of Taichi/Gaming K4 and whatever other board I review will be revisited and tested with two different types of 3200MHz RAM with whatever the latest UEFI version is for each product. Stay tuned! lots of more motherboard reviews coming.
  • damric
    Another THW review of a Killer board that doesn't include testing the Killer network software.
  • __Isomorph__
    terk, is there any advantage whatsoever to have VRM @ 16 vs 12 phases? and if no difference, then why the hell is it necessary for the Taichi to have a 16 phase VRM? most other boards i see out there from rival brands are at 8 or 10. please help me make sense of this cryptic nonsense.
  • turbotong
    #PLACEHOLDER_## comment about the #PLACEHOLDER_## article.
  • theterk
    @Isomorph, not all phases are created equal. A 16 phase board doesn't necessarily perform better than a 10 phase board.

    Ideally, more phases allocated to a particular voltage rail decreases signal noise, component wear, and in some cases increases redundancy. This is useful for overclocking since any noise induced by your workload or overclocking could potentially cause your system to crash. This also assists in spreading the heat produced by the VRMs to different components increasing the likelihood of stability.

    Obligatory link to an old article: http://www.hardwaresecrets.com/everything-you-need-to-know-about-the-motherboard-voltage-regulator-circuit/4/
  • pjgowtham
    Asus prime x370 pro review please :D??
  • CTPAHHIK
    Great review - thank you very much!!!
  • rugrat
    The lead sentence on my homepage RSS feed is:

    "Will the X370 Gaming K4 continue the Fatal1ty tradition regardless of the notion that Ryzen is..."

    I came here to finish that sentence,... It's not in the article. Now I'm going to wonder for the rest of the day,..."i wonder what the notion is about Ryzen."
  • Crashman
    112646 said:
    The lead sentence on my homepage RSS feed is: "Will the X370 Gaming K4 continue the Fatal1ty tradition regardless of the notion that Ryzen is..." I came here to finish that sentence,... It's not in the article. Now I'm going to wonder for the rest of the day,..."i wonder what the notion is about Ryzen."
    You're looking at the subtitle (I won't quite call it a Lede) for the article, which can be read on the "motherboards" category page:
    http://www.tomshardware.com/t/motherboards/
  • rugrat
    Thanks Crashman,...There's a heading and then a partial sentence that strikes me as part of the actual article. I guess I'm thinking of a "lead in" or first sentence of the article but subtitle works. Not being able to finish the subtitle myself brought me to the article,...alas, no happy ending.

    Thanks again for the link,...now I'll go and find the notion that Ryzen is....:bounce:

    "...terrible at gaming."!?...:heink:
  • Crashman
    112646 said:
    Thanks Crashman,...There's a heading and then a partial sentence that strikes me as part of the actual article. I guess I'm thinking of a "lead in" or first sentence of the article but subtitle works. Not being able to finish the subtitle myself brought me to the article,...alas, no happy ending. Thanks again for the link,...now I'll go and find the notion that Ryzen is....:bounce: "...terrible at gaming."!?...:heink:
    LOL, I guess it's fighting that notion. As is the editor. He's found that when you use a weak-enough graphics card, it can game as well as anything from Intel. The sad part is, "weak enough" is GTX 970. Yeh, we all need new graphics cards now :/
  • Ramin rostami
    BOYS do you know ryzen cpu is too smoot than intel 7700, very low latency in games and ..., very smooth in games because ryzen GRAPHIC CARD, mouse ,keyboard directly connect to ryzen cpu ! see am4 and 270 board diagram
    http://uupload.ir/files/7kxp_crosshair-diagram-1280x1024.jpg
    note= (in intel below picture intel has PCI3 out from cpu but it is cpu internal graphic out,not independant in )!!!!!
    http://uupload.ir/view/6fej_z270-diagram.png
  • __Isomorph__
    where do you get this notion from?

    i read and watched everything i could get my hands on re Ryzen, mobos, VRM and voltage phases, and i feel pretty comfortable now to say that there's been a lot of FUD that has been spread ignorantly or willfully about Ryzen.

    for those short on time, this video says it all loud and clear and is the mandatory watch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ylvdSnEbL50 .

    Ryzen is the superior CPU. and ASRock Taichi is the better mobo for stable OC'ing: https://level1techs.com/article/fastest-ryzen-1800x-system-world-2017-03-20


    1 said:
    Will the X370 Gaming K4 continue the Fatal1ty tradition regardless of the notion that Ryzen is terrible at gaming? ASRock X370 Gaming K4 ATX Motherboard Review : Read more
  • Crashman
    2449301 said:
    where do you get this notion from? i read and watched everything i could get my hands on re Ryzen, mobos, VRM and voltage phases, and i feel pretty comfortable now to say that there's been a lot of FUD that has been spread ignorantly or willfully about Ryzen. for those short on time, this video says it all loud and clear and is the mandatory watch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ylvdSnEbL50 . Ryzen is the superior CPU. and ASRock Taichi is the better mobo for stable OC'ing: https://level1techs.com/article/fastest-ryzen-1800x-system-world-2017-03-20
    1 said:
    Will the X370 Gaming K4 continue the Fatal1ty tradition regardless of the notion that Ryzen is terrible at gaming? ASRock X370 Gaming K4 ATX Motherboard Review : Read more
    It only did poorly in games at launch when a super-powerful graphics card was used. From launch day forward, we saw AMD fanboys using graphics-bottlenecked configurations to prove that Ryzen was just as good in games and better at a few other things. People were angry at Tom's Hardware for not skewing its configuration in this manner.

    Since then, there have been several software and firmware patches to improve the performance of Ryzen in places where it had done poorly. But the notion remains.
  • __Isomorph__
    ok but then what do you make of this? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0tfTZjugDeg

    when the scottish dude switches over to dual RX480 a whole new story unfolds and he concludes the shitty NVidia DX12 driver is to blame as we can see how on par with the 7700K Ryzen 1800X is, once it's the AMD DX12 driver who is in charge.
  • Oranthal
    309219 said:
    An in-depth review of Taichi/Gaming K4 and whatever other board I review will be revisited and tested with two different types of 3200MHz RAM with whatever the latest UEFI version is for each product. Stay tuned! lots of more motherboard reviews coming.


    What ram would you use with the Gaming K4 mobo at a budget of $150 or less for at least 16gb? What is the fastest memory you have gotten to work?