Pros, Cons & Final Verdict
Cooler Master took its time developing the MasterWatt Maker 1200, but our evaluation shows it's not up to the level we were expecting. Given its price tag, this unit should be on par with Corsair's flagship AX1500i. That's not the case, though. Corsair offers more power, higher performance, and a lower price tag. On top of that, Cooler Master's Connect software still needs lots of development work to match the functionality and accuracy you get from Corsair Link.
In reality, there's no comparison between the MasterWatt Maker 1200 and AX1500i. Corsair leans on an almost all-digital platform, while Cooler Master only uses an MCU as a digital bridge between your system and its PSU. The MasterWatt Maker 1200's only advantage is its Bluetooth interface and the corresponding application. The ability to monitor/control your PSU through a smart mobile device is indeed a nice idea, and we expect other manufacturers to adopt it in the near future.
The MasterWatt unit offers high efficiency above 80W loads. Under that point, efficiency is particularly poor, putting to shame its Titanium badge. Nonetheless, the lowest load for which the 80 PLUS Titanium certification sets a minimum efficiency reading is 10% of maximum capacity, leaving a lot of room for manufacturers to get sloppy. In our opinion, an efficiency certification should take into consideration more load levels and combinations like we do in our cross-load tests.
Cooler Master's most notable advantages are its high efficiency levels between 10% and 100% load, good ripple suppression, and the +12V rail's amazing response in transient loads. The PSU also features quiet operation, even in its default mode. Set to Silent, the MasterWatt Maker 1200's fan is deactivated under light loads and normal operating temperatures. The fan itself exudes quality, and the number of cables/connectors Cooler Master includes should allow you to build a very capable PC.
Unfortunately, there are also a lot of shortcomings to mention. The most obvious is a high price tag, though we can't forget about those low efficiency numbers under light loads and a hold-up time shorter than 17ms. Moreover, we were troubled by the push-button power switch's reliability issue. We broke it without even trying, forcing us to ask why Cooler Master didn't use a rocker switch instead. The MasterWatt Maker 1200 has issues with loose load regulation on its 5VSB rail and mediocre load regulation performance on the minor rails.
For $450, you get an enormous PSU featuring unique aesthetics and generally good build quality, though, at that price, we were expecting Japanese capacitors exclusively. Performance-wise, the MasterWatt has nothing innovative to show. When you show up with a higher price tag than Corsair's mighty AX1500i, you'd better be ready to match its performance or at least come close. Cooler Master urgently needs to cut the price on its MasterWatt Maker 1200, and then fix some of the issues we found. Otherwise, this power supply won't survive against Corsair and EVGA. Here's hoping that the next high-end PSU from Cooler Master is based on a true digital platform.
MORE: Best Power Supplies
MORE: Power Supplies 101
MORE: How We Test Power Supplies
MORE: Picking The Right Power Supply: What You Should Know
MORE: Computer History: From The Antikythera Mechanism To The Modern Era
MORE: All Power Supply Content
