Oculus Rift Vs. HTC Vive Vs. PlayStation VR

What's Included In The Box And Setup

Let’s first take a look at what you get in each box. For the sake of a fairness, we're using the PlayStation VR bundle that includes the camera (a necessary component) and the optional Move controllers. Although the Rift does not include any motion controls in the box, by the time PSVR ships, the Oculus Touch controllers should be available and there will likely be a bundle that includes the Rift and Touch in one box.

 HTC Vive

Oculus Rift

PlayStation VR
Bundle
HardwareVive HMD with integrated camera and mic

Base stations for tracking (2)

Base station mounting kits (2)

Link box (cable breakout box with optional Mini DisplayPort out, Bluetooth wireless connection to base stations and cell phone)

In-ear stereo headphones with 30cm cord
Rift HMD with integrated supra-aural headphones (removable) and mic

Constellation tracking camera sensor with stand

Bluetooth wireless media remote

PlayStation VR HMD

PlayStation camera for tracking

PlayStation VR processing unit (cable breakout box and splitter to send undistorted version of VR content to TV)

In-ear stereo headphones




Power3m base station power adapters (2)

1.2m link box power adapter

PlayStation VR Processing Unit power adapter


Cables5m HMD 3-in-1 cable (HDMI 1.4/USB 2.0/power, attached)

~0.5m HMD to headphone audio pass-through cable (attached)

1m HDMI 1.4 cable (link box to PC)

1m USB 2.0 cable (link box to PC)

15m optional base station sync cable
4m HMD 2-in-1 cable (HDMI 1.3/USB 3.0, attached)

2.5m tracking camera sensor cable (USB 3.0)









1.5m HMD 2-in-1 cable with inline remote (HDMI/USB 2.0, attached)

~2.5m HMD 2-in-1 cable to processing unit (HDMI/USB 2.0)

~2m processing unit to PlayStation 4 HDMI cable

~2m processing unit to PlayStation 4 micro-USB to USB cable


ControlsVive wireless controllers with lanyard (2)

For charging:

Controller power adapters (2)

Controller micro-USB cables (2)



Xbox One wireless controller

Wireless adapter for Windows

AA batteries (2)

USB extender cable for wireless adapter
PlayStation Move motion controllers (2)

For charging:

PlayStation Move controller mini USB to USB cables (2)




MiscellaneousCleaning cloth

Additional interchangeable foam face cushion (narrow)

Link box mounting pad

Cleaning cloth

Rift carrying case

Headphone removal tool


SoftwareFantastic Contraption game

Job Simulator game

The Lab game (mini-game collection)

Tilt Brush application
Lucky’s Tale game

Farlands game




PlayStation VR demo disc (demos of select launch titles)

PlayStation VR Worlds game
(mini-game collection)

HTC Vive Box Contents

Out of the three systems, HTC's Vive clearly comes with the most components. As the only VR system capable of room-scale VR out of the box, the Vive naturally needs more hardware, and you get a lot for your money. HTC doesn't leave out anything; it includes all of the cables you need, plus chargers for the controllers and an optional wired sync cable for the base stations (by default they sync wirelessly). HTC also bundles useful extras like a second (narrower) foam gasket for users with different facial structures.

The Vive includes the most generous selection of free software, with two full games, a mini-game collection and a VR application (Tilt Brush, a VR art program). HTC says the free games are promotional though, and it's not clear how long the offer will last. Also, HTC does leave out the short USB extension cable that came with the Vive Pre; it's used to plug in accessories to the HMD's second USB port.

The problem with having all those components to hook up is that the Vive's setup is the most complex. There are lots of wires to worry about! Also, even though this platform does support seated and standing VR, you need to configure everything, even if you don’t plan to use, or have the space for, room-scale VR. To use the Vive at all, the base station trackers have to be set up in opposite corners of the tracked space or in front of you, depending on what you plan to do.

Oculus Rift Box Contents

Compared to the Vive, the Rift’s box is positively minimalist. There are only two cables to worry about: one from the HMD and one from the tracking camera. There is no breakout box, so you plug them straight into your PC, and there are no power adapters to worry about either. Once the Rift is connected, you simply pair the wireless Xbox One controller and you’re ready to go. Oculus includes a wireless media remote for menu navigation and controlling some simple interactive content, such as ported Gear VR games.

At the moment, though, the Rift only supports seated and standing VR experiences. Later this year when the Oculus Touch motion controllers ship, you’ll need to set up a second tracking camera, which means one more cable to attach. Also, the lack of a breakout box could be problematic. If you trip on a cable, the point of failure is where it plugs into your PC rather than the external box. Still, compared to the Vive, the Rift is the easiest to set up.

Oculus also provides some free games with the Rift: Lucky’s Tale, a third-person VR platformer, and Farlands, an Animal Crossing-like game set on an alien world. The Rift comes packed in a useful carrying case that holds the headset, camera and controllers. One accessory disappointingly lacking is an additional interchangeable facial interface and spacer for users who wear glasses. You're forced to buy that separately.

PlayStation VR Bundle Box Contents

Like the Vive, PlayStation VR will come with lots of parts to plug in. Along with the HMD and bundled camera, there's also the PSVR Processing Unit. Despite its name, this isn't some sort of external GPU for improving performance. Rather, it provides 3D audio processing and displays an undistorted version of the VR game on your TV. For this to work, you need to hook up your existing PS4 HDMI cable from your TV to the Processing Unit.

One nice feature of PlayStation VR’s design is that the cable running out of the HMD has an inline remote for volume and playback control, and connects to another smaller breakout box at the end of a longer cable. This box helps prevents an accident from pulling your whole VR setup to the ground. The Move controllers included in the bundle do not have their own charger, so you have to hook them up to the PS4 with the included USB cable to charge them, which is a pain. At least Sony sells a dock for them separately, if you need it.

Sony is the least generous of the three when it comes to free software. Its PlayStation VR bundle only includes a demo disc with some (not yet announced) launch titles and PlayStation VR Worlds. This disc is a collection of mini-games including London Heist, which we had a lot of fun with when we tried it.

Hardware Setup Differences

The number of setup items varies, ranging from the Oculus Rift's four up to seven on the Vive. Add in the associated cables, and HTC's Vive is the most complex system to get running.

SteamVR Hardware Calibration For HTC Vive VR

The video above from our Vive review shows part of the setup process, which is calibrating the hardware and mapping out the play space for room-scale VR. Before you even get to this stage, you have to position the base stations in opposite corners of the room, either mounted to the wall, set on a high shelf or on a (not included) tripod/stand. There is also the breakout box, HMD and cables to connect. It’s not that the process is especially difficult, it’s just that there is a lot to do and it's time consuming.

Although we haven’t set up a PlayStation VR ourselves, it looks like it will run a close second to the Vive due to its mass of wires, breakout box, TV-mounted camera and motion controllers that need to be calibrated. In contrast, the Rift’s setup is ironically console-like. All you have to do is connect the camera, HMD and Xbox controller, and go through a short calibration process. Of course, once the Rift’s Touch controllers are available, the setup time will increase.

Loading...

This thread is closed for comments
23 comments
    Your comment
  • nitrium
    Apparently the PSVR has already been hacked to work on PCs (and Sony is considering official PC support after launch) - I wonder if it might be the best headset to get IF you have a PC, given that from this article at least the number one issue with PSVR is the PS4 it's being attached to.
  • problematiq
    I feel the PSVR got a bit over hyped in this article, in all fairness though it's not released yet so not a lot to go on. As an owner of the HTC Vive I can say "Yes your face will get warm/sweaty if you are in a warm room". I keep a fan blowing tword the center of the room to fix that problem, plus it makes me feel like I'm feeling the wind in VR. o.o All in all was the best purchase I've made in sometime. My wife who does not really like to play games enjoys it A LOT. It is also just a really hard experience to describe other than "Awesome". I don't know how I would feel without the full room scale and motion controllers, I think it would feel novel like playing games in 3D, sure it's cool but not practical and after a while your glasses sit there gathering dust. The ability to reach over and more or less grab and object, play around with it and even toss it, I'm just not sure how I could take off the HMD and put on the Rift and have an experience as good as that of the Vive. All of the HMD's are heading twords the same goal in the end though and it's evident.
  • Jeff Fx
    >and they don't have low refresh rate displays

    I think you wrote "low" when you meant "high."
  • Zapin
    So comparing one currently non-existant HMD to two others (one of which is still an incomplete experience) that run on a totally separate platform? Makes sense to me.
  • picture_perfect
    Wait for Polaris / Pascal cards later this month which will be 2X faster in VR apps. Well that is the Nvidia claim. Other VR specifics mentioned like (ray trace audio, specialized projection ect.). These are the first "VR cards".
  • Sven Viking
    The C:-drive-only issue was fixed a while ago, by the way, though (for now at least) you still need to choose one drive and stick to it rather than being able to split games between drives.

    For international pricing, don't forget to take high shipping costs and (for Vive to AU/NZ at least) customs fees into account.
  • problematiq
    17265 said:
    Wait for Polaris / Pascal cards later this month which will be 2X faster in VR apps. Well that is the Nvidia claim. Other VR specifics mentioned like (ray trace audio, specialized projection ect.). These are the first "VR cards".


    I run a 980 TI with the Vive and my load barely see's 30% I'm not sure what you are gaining for waiting on a "VR Card"
  • Deric_
    How can PSVR do roomscale with only a single camera?
    Your controllers will get occluded everytime your body is between them and the camera.
    If you have to face a single direction to play, then it is not room scale.
  • alex davies
    Quote:
    Apparently the PSVR has already been hacked to work on PCs (and Sony is considering official PC support after launch) - I wonder if it might be the best headset to get IF you have a PC, given that from this article at least the number one issue with PSVR is the PS4 it's being attached to.


    A PC-compatible PSVR would only be the best VR headset from a price perspective. Yes, having a PC power it would improve the fidelity of the in-game graphics, but despite being the most ergonomic, it's still a step below both the Rift and Vive technically. Well, Rift + Touch, because as the moment the lack of tracked controllers handicaps the Rift.
  • alex davies
    Quote:
    >and they don't have low refresh rate displays I think you wrote "low" when you meant "high."


    Fixed, thanks!
  • alex davies
    Quote:
    So comparing one currently non-existant HMD to two others (one of which is still an incomplete experience) that run on a totally separate platform? Makes sense to me.


    If you read the content of the article, you will see that I address this numerous times and only compare what is currently known about all three headsets, based the Rift and Vive we own and our usage of PlayStation VR at various press events. For example, in the software section, we don't talk about PSVR as much because there are still a lot of unknowns.
  • alex davies
    Quote:
    The C:-drive-only issue was fixed a while ago, by the way, though (for now at least) you still need to choose one drive and stick to it rather than being able to split games between drives. For international pricing, don't forget to take high shipping costs and (for Vive to AU/NZ at least) customs fees into account.


    Unfortunately, with the time it took to write and edit such a detailed article, there were some facts that are now out of date, such as the Oculus installation drive issue, and it's good to know that it has been fixed. That still doesn't change the fact that Oculus Home is still significantly behind SteamVR's UX, and Valve keeps adding new features almost every week.

    As for shipping and customs information for international pricing, that would have simply been too much info to include in that table.
  • DotNetMaster777
    price/quality comparison ???
  • alex davies
    Quote:
    How can PSVR do roomscale with only a single camera? Your controllers will get occluded everytime your body is between them and the camera. If you have to face a single direction to play, then it is not room scale.


    I mention that in the article: "For PSVR room-scale VR, the single point of tracking along with the single tracking camera means there is likely to be some occlusion." Because the HMD can be tracked 360° room-scale is still possible, but, yes, the experience will not be optimal as on the Vive.
  • darth_adversor
    Amazing that some people can afford a 980ti and HTC Vive, but can't spell "toward."
  • Brandon_29
    Quote:
    Amazing that some people can afford a 980ti and HTC Vive, but can't spell "toward."


    It is amazing that retards still bother to spell-check comments. Also, it is quite obvious that this was a typo and not a spelling mistake. Maybe if you put your efforts towards something useful you could afford a nice setup as well.

    Now to play with you a bit. Proper English for your response would be.

    "
    It is amazing that some people can afford to buy a 980ti and a HTC Vive, but cannot spell "toward".
    "

    You made several mistakes in your own sentence so who are you to judge?
  • darth_adversor
    Quote:
    Quote:
    Amazing that some people can afford a 980ti and HTC Vive, but can't spell "toward."
    It is amazing that retards still bother to spell-check comments. Also, it is quite obvious that this was a typo and not a spelling mistake. Maybe if you put your efforts towards something useful you could afford a nice setup as well. Now to play with you a bit. Proper English for your response would be. " It is amazing that some people can afford to buy a 980ti and a HTC Vive, but cannot spell "toward". " You made several mistakes in your own sentence so who are you to judge?


    It would be "an HTC Vive," not "a HTC Vive."

    My "setup" is VR-ready, thank you very much. I'm merely waiting for prices to drop before I jump in.
  • ravnoscc
    Excellent comparison with the information you had available. As each of these platform VR experiences matures I hope we'll see a revisit of this article?
  • Badelhas
    This was a GREAT GREAT article, Congrats to the editor!

    One question though: any indication about availability in other countries, like Portugal?

    Cheers
  • Peter_136
    Thank you for this *excellent* article! Very even-handed and fair, highlighting the pros and cons of each headset. Having tried in-store demos of both currently-available units, I can vouch for the differences in ergonomics and interactivity. The Rift looks and feels better, but it cannot be understated how much room-scale tracking and motion controls add to the overall experience.

    I just cancelled my shipping-in-June Rift pre-order due to the uncertainty currently surrounding Touch, but once that's resolved I fully intend to pick up either a CV1 or a Vive.
  • Blas
    Here's a Spain store's page for the PlayStation's HMD:

    http://www.pccomponentes.com/sony_playstation_vr_gafas_realidad_virtual.html?from=UpSell&vt_campaign=1001668&vt_content=10002040

    Priced at €400, available as from October the 21st 2016. Of course price may change until then, but it's an indication...
  • Dean_23
  • problematiq
    1927107 said:
    Great article. By far PSVR is the best compromise, in fact it's what will save high-end VR. The Oculus at 700€ (as to be shipped) was a disappointment, although it's the lightest and lest tethered and has built-in spatial headset, as a low FOV but most importantly almost no content. The Vive at 900€, was a mess, it has the room-tracking, chaperone and controller but the set-up (11 fucking cables with a gigantic box), the lousy Steam software you have to update, install, and run, and the inexactitude of tracking is annoying. Then there's lots of shit content, and few worthy room-scale experience. More importanly, they both require a very recent and expensive PC, which means you have to use Wincrap and all it's mess and problems (15 millions user base according to Nvidia), and you tied to you desktop environnement. PSVR on the other is 500€, as the best design and confort (because of the quick remove slide), is multiplayer and social, has spatial audio, and seem to have the best experiences available for it. But most importantly it's cheap and available on a cheap but optimised and straight-forward system (50 millions user base by release).


    I feel as though your comment is based without use of any VR headset.
    the Vive's 11 cables you have to plug in really equate to making sure you have power to your two base stations and that your HMD is plugged in. you have a cable running to it but it is a siamese cable it really feels like just a single cable. Your comment read's like the PSVR doesn't have any cables, It does.
    With Nvidia's release of the pascal series, and soon AMD's release of the 400 series, you will be able to buy a VR ready box for around 500$ (using a 1070 most likely will start you out at 600$) so around the same price as a PS 4 VR ready bundle (500$) Thats without the HMD of course.
    As far as cost for the HMD's PSVR is a lot cheaper.. in more than one way. You get what you pay for with the HMD's I've tried both Oculus and Vive.
    If you already have a PS4 thats great..but a whole lot of people already have a PC. to meet the requirements add a 200-300$ GPU upgrade (if you dont already have one)
    Content.. there is no PSVR content so I'm not sure what your are going on about. also with the use of Steam you have quite a lot to pick from and I suspect by the end of the year it will further explode.
    Windows.. ok you have a full OS with the ability to do whatever you wish. don't like windows? use Linux.
    ALL SOFTWARE REQUIRES UPDATES! your PS4 requires updates too AGAIN not sure what you are even referring to.
    Desktop environment, Both Oculus and Vive have a custom environment with which you launch games from.. while wearing the VR HMD, much like your console for PS4.