Haswell And Richland Memory Scaling: Picking A 16 GB DDR3 Kit

Test Settings And Overclocking

Why you can trust Tom's Hardware Our expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing products and services so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about how we test.

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Test System Configuration
AMD CPUAMD A10-6800K (Richland): 4.1-4.4 GHz, 4 MB L2 Cache, Socket FM2, Overclocked to 4.50 GHz at 1.425 V
Intel CPUIntel Core i7-4770K (Haswell): 3.5-3.9 GHz, 8 MB L3 Cache, LGA 1150, Overclocked to 4.50 GHz at 1.25 V
AMD MotherboardAsus F2A85-V Pro Rev 1.03, BIOS 6104 (05/08/2013)
Intel MotherboardAsus Z87-Pro Rev 1.02, BIOS 1007 (05/17/2013)
AMD GraphicsIntegrated Radeon HD 8670D, 0.84 GHz
Intel GraphicsIntegrated HD Graphics 4600, 1.25 GHz
RAMG.Skill F3-17600CL9D-8GBXLD (8 GB) at DDR3-1600 C9 Defaults
Hard DriveSamsung 840 Series MZ-7PD256, 256 GB SSD
SoundIntegrated HD Audio
NetworkIntegrated Gigabit Networking
PowerCorsair AX860i: ATX12V v2.3, EPS12V, 80 PLUS Platinum
Software
OSMicrosoft Windows 8 Professional RTM x64
AMD PlatformAMD Catalyst 13.4
Intel GraphicsVersion 9.18.10.3111
Intel ChipsetIntel INF 9.4.0.1017

When we heard that AMD’s previous-generation motherboards would work with its new-generation processors, we were happy to pull out Asus’ top-overclocking F2A85-V Pro and give it a simple BIOS update.

Our Asus Z87-Pro sample already had firmware of similar vintage to the F2A85-V Pro’s update, so we left it alone.

Scuttlebutt says that AMD’s A10-6800K reaches 4.5 GHz without much effort, but our sample needed 1.425 V to achieve complete stability. It would easily run 4.4 GHz at 1.30 V, so perhaps 4.5 GHz wasn’t a good target?

The problem with 4.4 GHz was that we didn’t want to give the firm a frequency handicap in an article that includes Intel. Our Core i7-4770K was easily running 4.5 GHz at 1.250 V maximum, and we began testing before AMD's sample arrived.

And so the test began with the Intel processor at 4.50 GHz, secure in the knowledge that both CPUs would support DDR3-2400 via overclocking. Two of the kits were DDR3-2400-rated. And one of the kits would even run at DDR3-2666.

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Best DRAM Timings at 1.65 V: Intel Core i7-4770K
Row 0 - Cell 0 Max MT/s 12-15-15-35DDR3-2400 OptimizedDDR3-2133 OptimizedDDR3-1866 OptimizedDDR3-1600 Optimized
Adata XPG V2 AX3U2400W8G11-DMV240011-12-11-3010-11-10-279-9-9-247-8-8-21
AMD Gamer Series AG316G2130U2K213311-13-12-3010-11-10-279-10-9-248-8-8-21
Crucial Ballistix Tactical BLT2KIT8G3D1869DT1TX02133Failed9-10-10-278-8-8-247-7-7-21
G.Skill Ripjaws X F3-14900CL10D-16GBXL240011-12-12-309-10-10-278-9-9-247-8-8-21
Mushkin Redline Ridgeback 997121R240010-12-11-309-10-9-278-9-9-247-8-8-21
Patriot Viper 3 PV316G240C0KRD266610-12-11-309-10-10-278-9-9-247-8-7-21

AMD’s Richland-based A10 pushed better timings out of these modules at several settings, but its integrated graphics engine was not stable at DDR3-2400. After several attempts to adjust memory controller and DRAM voltage to compensate that instability, I eventually found that increasing the APU from the stock 1.20 V to 1.50 V granted temporary stability. This allowed theoretical XMP-2400 performance data to be gathered on the AMD platform, but you’ll see those results discredited throughout the article.

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Best DRAM Timings at 1.65 V: AMD A10-6800K
Row 0 - Cell 0 Max MT/s 12-15-15-35DDR3-2400 OptimizedDDR3-2133 OptimizedDDR3-1866 OptimizedDDR3-1600 Optimized
Adata XPG V2 AX3U2400W8G11-DMV2133Failed10-11-10-278-9-9-247-8-7-21
AMD Gamer Series AG316G2130U2K2133Failed10-11-10-278-10-9-248-8-8-21
Crucial Ballistix Tactical BLT2KIT8G3D1869DT1TX02133Failed9-10-9-278-8-8-247-7-7-21
G.Skill Ripjaws X F3-14900CL10D-16GBXL2133Failed9-10-9-278-9-8-247-8-7-21
Mushkin Redline Ridgeback 997121R2133Failed9-10-9-278-9-8-247-8-7-21
Patriot Viper 3 PV316G240C0KRD2133Failed9-10-9-278-9-8-247-8-7-21

The System Builder Marathon gaming suite is easily adapted to integrated graphics performance evaluation by lowering its resolution and/or details to Intel HD Graphics 4600-compliant levels. The HD 8760D won’t even break a sweat.

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Benchmark Configuration
3D Games
Battlefield 3Campaign Mode, "Going Hunting" 90-Sec. Fraps Test Settings: Medium Quality Defaults (No AA, 4x AF)
F1 2012Steam Version, In-Game Test Test Settings: High Quality Preset, No AA
The Elder Scrolls V: SkyrimUpdate 1.5.26, Celedon Aethirborn Level 6, 25-Sec. Fraps Test Settings: Medium Quality Defualts (4x AA, 0x AF)
Far Cry 3V. 1.04, DirectX 11, 50-sec. Fraps "Amanaki Outpost" Test Settings: Medium Quality, No AA, Standard ATC., SSAO
Synthetic Benchmarks and Settings
SiSoftware Sandra 2013Version 2013.01.19.11, CPU Test = CPU Arithmetic / Cryptography, Memory Test = Bandwidth Benchmark
Thomas Soderstrom is a Senior Staff Editor at Tom's Hardware US. He tests and reviews cases, cooling, memory and motherboards.