Premium Controllers Under Scrutiny: Ultra160 RAID Adapters from Adaptec and LSI

Comparison Of Technical Specifications

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Header Cell - Column 0 Adaptec 2110SLSI MegaRAID Elite 1650
Card sizeHalf heightFull height
Bus64/32 bit PCI 2.264/32 bit PCI 2.2
SCSI channelssingle channel, internal & externalDual channel, internal & external
RAID mode0, 1, 0/1, 5, 0/50, 1, 1/0, 3, 3/0, 5, 5/0
Max. No. of drives1530
Cache32 MB ECC on-board32-256 MB ECC via DIMM
Hardware XORIntel GC80302Intel GC80303
OS supportedNetware, Windows NT/2000/XP/NET, Unix/Linux, DOS, FreeBSDNetware, Windows NT/2000/XP/NET, Unix/Linux, DOS, Solaris
Capacity extensionOn the flyOn the fly (FlexRAID)
RAID initializationIn the backgroundIn the background

RAID 5/0 and RAID 0/5 differ in the way in which the two fundamental modes are combined. In the case of 5/0 (LSI), several RAID 5 arrays are pooled in stripesets, in order to up performance. The benefit of this is that a drive can fail in each of the RAID 5 sets without the RAID being forced to its knees. RAID 0/5 (Adaptec) requires at least three stripesets, in order to be able to compile a RAID 5. This means that the failure of as few as two drives in different stripsets would put an end to the RAID 0/5.

The disadvantage of Adaptec: a RAID 0/5 is slowed significantly by the restriction to a single Ultra160 channel. Allocation to two channels makes sense here.

TOPICS
Patrick Schmid
Editor-in-Chief (2005-2006)

Patrick Schmid was the editor-in-chief for Tom's Hardware from 2005 to 2006. He wrote numerous articles on a wide range of hardware topics, including storage, CPUs, and system builds.