VGA Card Buyer's Guide 07/2003

The Price Categories

Graphics cards can be roughly divided into three price ranges, each of which can again be further subdivided into two price segments. The edges between these classes are blurred, though, due in large part to fluctuations in market prices. The two big players in the 3D graphics field, ATi and NVIDIA, offer various versions of their chips in the different price classes. Again, there are two variations of each of these chips, a standard version and a faster one with higher clockspeeds and improved performance. ATi denotes chips of this second category with a "PRO" added onto the name, while NVIDIA uses "Ultra."

The two companies follow differing market strategies as well. NVIDIA concentrates completely on developing and producing graphics chips and does not manufacture or sell its own cards. ATi, on the other hand, does sell its own line of cards ("Built by ATi"), albeit only in the US and Canada. Additionally, partner companies also sell products based on ATi's chips ("Powered by ATi").

Another factor that makes it even more difficult to divide cards into price categories has to do with the older-generation cards, which seem to be getting cheaper every day. In this article, we'll only look at the "youngest" last-generation cards. There are especially pronounced differences between ATi and NVIDIA products here. ATi's last generation (Radeon 9500 and 9700), for example, can still be considered up to date, feature-wise (DirectX 9 and multi sampling FSAA). The Radeon 9000 and the newer 9200, which are based on the Radeon 8500 design and therefore only support DirectX 8 and use the slower super sampling FSAA technique, are the notable exceptions.

From a technological aspect, NVIDIA's last-gen cards are outdated: while the GeForce4 Ti already employs multi sampling FSAA, it only supports DirectX 8, and the GeForce4 MX is a remnant of the DirectX 7 era and still uses super sampling FSAA. Nonetheless, a GeForce4 Ti4200 is still able to outperform an FX 5600 in some games, since it has more pixel pipelines at its disposal.

At the bottom end of the graphics card spectrum you'll find the low budget cards, which we've divided into price segments of either under $100 or between $100 and $150. Typical representatives of this entry-level card segment are often based on ATi's Radeon 9200 or NVIDIA's FX 5200. In the price range of up to $150, we also find PRO and Ultra versions of these chips and a few Radeon 9500s.

Next up is the mainstream segment, which ranges from $150 to $300. Most cards cost somewhere between $150 and $200 and use either ATi's Radeon 9500 PRO, 9600 or 9600 PRO or NVIDIA's GeForceFX 5600 or FX 5600 Ultra. The Radeon 9700 and 9700 PRO are found on boards costing up to $300.

Lastly, there is the enthusiast segment. Starting at $300 and reaching all the way up to $500, cards in this group sport the newest ATi and NVIDIA chips. NVIDIA's GeForceFX 5800, which was only introduced this spring, goes for $320, while the Ultra version of this card costs around $380. This is also the starting price for ATi's Radeon 9800 PRO, which can cost up to $420, depending on the feature set.

Since NVIDIA's newest offering, the FX 5900, is only now beginning to trickle into the retail channel, we don't have any street prices yet. According to NVIDIA, we will see three(!) versions of the chip, at the following prices: FX 5900 Value (starting at $299); FX 5900 (from $399); and FX 5900 Ultra (from $499). That puts the Ultra's price on the same level as that of the 256 MB version of ATi's Radeon 9800 PRO.

  1. VGA Buyer's Guide 07/2003
  2. The Price Categories
  3. An Overview Of The Cards
  4. ATi's Current Product Family
  5. Radeon 9600
  6. Radeon 9800
  7. NVIDIA's Current Product Family
  8. GeForceFX 5600
  9. GeForceFX 5900
  10. Other Chip Companies
  11. Notes On Our Noise Level Tests
  12. Benchmarks
  13. UT2003
  14. UT2003 4xFSAA & 8x Aniso
  15. Quake 3 Team Arena
  16. Quake 3 Team Arena 4xFSAA & 8x Aniso
  17. Gunmetal 4xFSAA
  18. ABIT
  19. ABIT Siluro FX 5600 Ultra DT, Continued
  20. ASUS
  21. ASUS V9520/TD, Continued
  22. ASUS V9560 Video Suite
  23. ASUS V9560 Video Suite, Continued
  24. Performance
  25. ASUS V9950
  26. ASUS V9950, Continued
  27. BFG Technology
  28. BFG Asylum GeForceFX 5600 256 MB AGP, Continued
  29. Performance
  30. Gainward
  31. Gainward FX PowerPack! Pro/760XP 128 MB Golden Sample, Continued
  32. Performance
  33. Gainward FX PowerPack! Ultra/760XP 128 MB Golden Sample
  34. Gainward FX PowerPack! Ultra/760XP 128 MB Golden Sample, Continued
  35. Performance
  36. Gainward FX PowerPack! Ultra/1200XP 128 MB Golden Sample
  37. Gainward FX PowerPack! Ultra/1200XP 128 MB Golden Sample, Contined
  38. Performance
  39. Gigabyte
  40. Gigabyte Radeon 9800 PRO 128 MB (GV-R98P128D), Continued
  41. Gigabyte Radeon 9800 PRO 256 MB (GV-R98P256D)
  42. Gigabyte Radeon 9800 PRO 256 MB (GV-R98P256D), Continued
  43. Inno3D
  44. Inno3D Tornado GeForceFX 5200, Continued
  45. Inno3D Tornado GeForceFX 5600
  46. Inno3D Tornado GeForceFX 5600, Continued
  47. Inno3D Tornado GeForceFX 5800
  48. Inno3D Tornado GeForceFX 5800, Continued
  49. Leadtek
  50. Leadtek WinFast A340 TDH, Continued
  51. Leadtek WinFast A340 Ultra TD MyVIVO
  52. Leadtek WinFast A340 Ultra TD MyVIVO, Continued
  53. Leadtek WinFast A310 Ultra TD MyVIVO
  54. Leadtek WinFast A310 Ultra TD MyVIVO, Continued
  55. Leadtek WinFast A300 TD MyVIVO
  56. Leadtek WinFast A300 TD MyVIVO, Continued
  57. Leadtek WinFast A300 TD MyVIVO, Continued
  58. Leadtek WinFast A300 Ultra TD MyVIVO
  59. Leadtek WinFast A300 Ultra TD MyVIVO, Continued
  60. Leadtek WinFast A300 Ultra TD MyVIVO, Continued
  61. Leadtek WinFast A350 TD MyVIVO
  62. Leadtek WinFast A350 TD MyVIVO, Continued
  63. Leadtek WinFast A350 TD MyVIVO, Continued
  64. MSI
  65. MSI FX5200-VTD128, Continued
  66. MSI FX5200-VTD128, Continued
  67. MSI FX5200-TDR128
  68. MSI FX5200-TDR128, Continued
  69. MSI FX5200U-TD128
  70. MSI FX5200U-TD128, Continued
  71. MSI FX5600-VTDR128 [Editor's Choice]
  72. MSI FX5600-VTDR128 [Editor's Choice], Continued
  73. MSI FX5600-VTDR128 [Editor's Choice], Continued
  74. MSI FX5900-TD128
  75. MSI FX5900-TD128, Continued
  76. MSI FX5900-TD128, Continued
  77. PixelView
  78. PixelView GeForceFX 5600, Continued
  79. Performance
  80. PowerColor
  81. PowerColor Radeon 9800 PRO, Continued
  82. Sparkle
  83. Sparkle GeForceFX 5600 (SP8831DV/ 128 MB DDR), Continued
  84. Tyan
  85. Tyan Tachyon G9600 PRO, Continued
  86. Conclusion
Create a new thread in the US Reviews comments forum about this subject
This thread is closed for comments
No comments yet
Comment from the forums
    Your comment