Two 2TB Hard Drives For Storage Applications, Reviewed

Comparison Table And Test Setup

ManufacturerSamsung
Seagate
Model
EcoGreen F3 Constellation ES
Model Number
HD203WIST32000644NS
Form Factor
3.5"3.5"
Capacity
2,000GB2,000GB
Spindle Speed5,400 RPM7,200 RPM
Other Capacities1,500GB500, 1,000GB
Platters4
4
Cache
32MB64MB
NCQ
Yes
Yes
InterfaceSATA 3Gb/s
SATA 3Gb/s
Operating Temperature0-60°C5-60°C
Specified Idle Power 5.4W7W
Measured Idle Power 4.1W6.4W
Operating Shock (2 ms, read)70 G70 G
Warranty
3 Years
5 Years


This review deals only with these two drives, but there are two more products that require consideration: Hitachi’s Ultrastar A7K2000, a 7,200 RPM business class drive, and two options by Western Digital, the Caviar Green that compares to Samsung’s F3EG and the RE4 (RAID Edition), which is more similar to the Constellation ES.

Test Setup

System Hardware
HardwareDetails
CPUIntel Core i7-920 (45 nm, 2.66 GHz, 8MB L3 Cache)
Motherboard (Sockel 1366)Supermicro X8SAX
Revision: 1.1, Chipset: Intel X58 + ICH10R, BIOS: 1.0B
RAM3 x 1GB DDR3-1333 Corsair CM3X1024-1333C9DHX
HDDSeagate NL35 400GB
ST3400832NS, 7,200 RPM, SATA/150, 8MB Cache
Power SupplyOCZ EliteXstream 800W
OCZ800EXS-EU
Benchmarks
Performance Measurementsh2benchw 3.12
PCMark Vantage 1.0
I/O PerformanceIOMeter 2006.07.27
Fileserver-Benchmark
Webserver-Benchmark
Database-Benchmark
Workstation-Benchmark
Streaming Reads
Streaming Writes
System Software & Drivers
DriverDetails
Operating SystemWindows Vista Ultimate SP1
Intel ChipsetChipset Installation Utility 9.1.0.1007
AMD GraphicsRadeon 8.12
Intel Matrix Storage8.7.0.1007