4:50 AM - 04/21/2008 by
Patrick Schmid, Achim Roos
- Email |
- Print |
- Comments (71) |
- Share
2.5" Hard Drives
| Manufacturer | Western Digital | Fujitsu | Seagate | Seagate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Model | VelociRaptor VR150 | MBB2 RC | Savvio 10K.2 | Savvio 15K.1 |
| Model Number | WD3000 | MBB2147RC | ST973402SS | ST973451SS |
| Form Factor | 2.5" | 2.5" | 2.5" | 2.5" |
| Capacity | 300 GB | 147 GB | 73 GB | 73 GB |
| Spindle Speed | 10,000 RPM | 10,000 RPM | 10,000 RPM | 15,000 RPM |
| Other Capacities | - | 73 GB | 36, 147 GB | 36 GB |
| Platters | 2 | 2 | 1 | 2 |
| Cache | 16 MB | 16 MB | 16 MB | 16 MB |
| NCQ | yes | yes | yes | yes |
| Interface | SATA/300 | SAS | SAS | SAS |
| Warranty | 5 years | 5 years | 5 years | 5 years |
3.5" Hard Drives
| Manufacturer | Hitachi | Samsung | Seagate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Model | Deskstar 7K1000 | Spinpoint F1 | Barracuda 7200.11 |
| Model Number | HDS721010KLA330 | HD103UJ | ST31000340AS |
| Form Factor | 3.5" | 3.5" | 3.5" |
| Capacity | 1000 GB | 1000 GB | 1000 GB |
| Spindle Speed | 7,200 RPM | 7,200 RPM | 7,200 RPM |
| Other Capacities | 750 GB | 160, 250, 320, 500, 640, 750 GB | 500, 750 GB |
| Platters | 5 | 3 | 4 |
| Cache | 32 MB | 32 MB | 32 MB |
| NCQ | yes | yes | yes |
| Interface | SATA/300 | SATA/300 | SATA/300 |
| Warranty | 3 years | 3 years | 5 years |
| Manufacturer | Western Digital | Western Digital | Western Digital |
|---|---|---|---|
| Model | Caviar GP | Caviar RE2-GP | Raptor |
| Model Number | WD10EACS | WD1000FYPS | WD1500ADFD |
| Form Factor | 3.5" | 3.5" | 3.5" |
| Capacity | 1000 GB | 1000 GB | 150 GB |
| Spindle Speed | > 5400 RPM | 7200 - 5400 RPM | 10000 RPM |
| Other Capacities | 500, 750 GB | 500, 750 GB | 36, 74 GB |
| Platters | 4 | 4 | 2 |
| Cache | 16 MB | 16 MB | 16 MB |
| NCQ | yes | yes | yes |
| Interface | SATA/300 | SATA/300 | SATA/150 |
| Warranty | 3 Years | 3 Years | 5 years |
Topics being discussed on the forums
- GA-EX58-UD4P SATA [Motherboards & Memory]
- New Extreme Gaming PC Build Compatability [Homebuilt Systems]
- FS: Awesome Entry Level Gaming Machine [Deals]
- Help setting up RAID [Homebuilt Systems]
- Asus Maximus II Formula Not recognizing 2nd Sata HDD [Motherboards & Memory]
Questions? Ask Tom's community!
- 1 / 4
- Next
-
Sponsored links
Related forums topics
- Need help with OCing E8500, Asust Striker Formula
- HELP! Asus P6T Deluxe: SATA HDD/IDE OPTICAL DRIVE and WIN XP 64-bit
- I7 Gaming PC
- Average? i7 build
- Extreme Gaming PC Build
- Gaming/Encoding build...
- Bottlenecking, psu and os questions
- new ssd raid-0 system setup
- SAS 15K RPM Drive 75GB for $60 Can this be used for OS ??
- advice on new hdd setup
- RAID setup help
- Looking for experienced RAID 0 users
Best offers
|
My Passport Essential 500GB Portable... | $129.99 STAPLES More info |
|
WD Elements External 1.5TB 3.5" Hard... | $119.99 Dell Home More info |
|
My Book Essential Edition External... | $148.00 ServerSupply.com More info |
|
Elements External 1TB 3.5" Hard Drive... | $94.99 Dell Home More info |
|
Caviar Green 2TB Hard Drive (SATA II,... | $199.99 STAPLES More info |
Popular Searches
- st31000340as
- hard drive comparisons
- st31000340as review
- 750 2.5 hard drive
- st31000340as jumper
- sata velociraptor
- western digital velociraptor 150
- st31000340as driver
- western digital drive comparison
- sata drive comparison
- sata drives comparison
- 2.5 500 gb hard drive comparison
- sata hard drive comparison
- western digital hard drive comparison
- spindle speed of hdd
Partners
The Games selection
violent :
Interactive Buddy
Unwind on your interactive buddy: Do anything you want to him, it will earn you money, and you can buy other stuff to torture him with.
|
crazy :
Interactive Boogy
Pick one of the 3 songs, hit on the correct keys matching this boy's dance moves.
|
Ads
Athauglas......on page 5 is the drive with the top plate removed..not with a clear window.
*drools*
Very nice and about time. Now, who has $300 to lend me.
LAME as all hell...mant new 320gb/platter drives are almost as fast with a lot better capacity and surely price.. ! This is like a raptor ME edition...zzzz
#1 - Finally! Tom's Seems to have gotten a scoop. It's been a while but it's nice to See Tom's have a major hardware review out before the others.
#2 - A very well written article. I've noticed an uptick in the quality of articles of late. Kudos again.
#3 - A very nice HDD. Something I may definitely look at adding to my system.
LAME as all hell...mant new 320gb/platter drives are almost as fast with a lot better capacity and surely price.. ! This is like a raptor ME edition...zzzz
Oh really, which ones?
western digital 640 aaks series b3 revision:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6822136218
Seagate 7200.11 (if they can work out their doa prob):
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6822148316
A few of samsung's F1 spinpoints...
they are all pretty close, especially seagate at 114mb STR, 60 low and around 100 average across 320 gigs.
A 150 gig drive that is just a bit higher is not so awesome, and yes I know seek times, IO and all that matter too. Do you really thonk the new raptor is gonna be 90 bucks like these, I sure don't.
If they at least have a 320 same performance, or the performance was closer to 150 (as in a larger 3.5 platter), then sure, but it's sad considering a 7200 is almost passing them ALREADY.
My bad, 300 gb does make it look beter ! but still those other drives are way to close considering this is the raptor series.
Well you answered it yourself i.e., seek and IO. You can't take read / write as the total picture. The drives you posted aren't really that close in read / write either. I'm sure you know the last bit of performance costs the most money.
You could say you don't think it's worth the cash, I have no problem with that, but it sounds a lot like sour grapes to me.
Seriously. Just what about this drive isn't impressive?
It has twice the storage space of the previous top model.
It has better benchmark results.
It runs cooler way cooler.
That IcePack is perfect for mounting behind front intake fans(improved airflow).
I'd want 1 over any 1TB drive. The price is also quite reasonable for a Raptor.
I'd call that progress in every way.
There's just no pleasing some people.
Honestly, who was expecting the next Raptor to be a 2.5 inch drive? I know it's in a 3.5 inch enclosure, but you just know the guys at Alienware are trying to figure out how one of these is going to work in a laptop.
About time they updated the raptors, they've been doing pretty poorly for quite a while. It's cool to see over 120MB/s read/write on a desktop drive.
I wonder why I/O performance isn't as good as the SAS drives even though it has faster read/write speeds and latency. Could this be fixed with firmware?
They look like a really nice answer to SSDs. I'm really considering getting one but $300 for a hard drive is a lot of money.
Hell, it'd be the most expensive component in my rig...
Honestly, who was expecting the next Raptor to be a 2.5 inch drive? I know it's in a 3.5 inch enclosure, but you just know the guys at Alienware are trying to figure out how one of these is going to work in a laptop.
Notebook HDs only need 5V and the velociRaptor needs both 12V and 5V. I'm not saying it can't be done.
It's not sour grapes...it's spoon feeding us tiny bumps and calling it amazing that gets me...it's better, but amazing or wow or making a big deal about an incremental increase is just hyping it up, when it's not that big of a step up.
Lets see how it looks to me:
- I get 30%+ of performance increase compared to my 1TB drive (yah, 10EACS)
- I get 300gb for $300, I already have 1000gb for $300
- I can get 640gb instead of 300gb with little speed decrease but it will cost $130.
So 30%+ speed increase equals almost 5x price increase? My wallet thinks otherwise... But thats my wallet, if your wallet says otherwise, I think you'll be happy with the new HDD from WD
^My wallet says I have to live with my Raptor, you know bills and stuff.
It's not sour grapes...it's spoon feeding us tiny bumps and calling it amazing that gets me...it's better, but amazing or wow or making a big deal about an incremental increase is just hyping it up, when it's not that big of a step up.
Hard drives have to live within the laws of physics and current technology. Maybe you know of some way to get a 200% improvement. By all means share it with us.
This drive looks good to me. If I hadn't just built a new computer, I'd like one of these in it. One might end up in the new computer anyway. Don't know, will see.
Hey wait, that government rebate check could pay for one of these and not hurt the wallet at all.
look up a hard drive from back in the day called a Chinook. How about some real innovation...I'll gladly pay out the nose for some.
2 actuators is better than one and not at all infeasible today.