Developer re-enables 3D printer features that Bambu Lab disabled, firm promptly threatens legal action — OrcaSlicer-BambuLab project now shuttered

Bambu Lab Orca Slicer
(Image credit: Tom's Hardware)

Independent software developer Pawel Jarczak has voluntarily shuttered his popular “OrcaSlicer-BambuLab” project following legal threats from Bambu Lab, ending one man’s fight to restore direct control to the popular third-party slicer. Jarczak’s fork of OrcaSlicer would have allowed users to bypass Bambu Connect, a middleware application that severely limits OrcaSlicer’s access to remote printer functions in the name of security.

Jarczak said in a note on GitHub that Bambu Lab threatened him with a cease and desist letter and accused him of reverse engineering its software in order to impersonate Bambu Studio. He said he was also accused of violating Bambu’s Terms of Use and bypassing authorization control. He chose to voluntarily remove the software. He insists he did nothing wrong as his fork of Orca only used publicly available source code.

“I explicitly pointed out that, according to Bambu Lab's own explanation, the reason the method still worked was simply that they had not disabled that path yet. In other words, the behavior they objected to was, by their own description, still possible within the Linux-side workflow they had not yet changed,” Jarczak wrote.

Latest Videos From

He also pointed out that Bambu Studio is publicly released under the AGPL-3.0 license, a “copyleft” Open Source license that PrusaSlicer uses. As Bambu Studio uses PrusaSlicer’s code as its foundation, it must allow the core program to remain open source.

For many, brand-agnostic Orca Slicer was THE gold standard of 3D printing slicers. It’s a fork of Bambu Studio (which is itself a fork of Prusa Slicer), developed by SoftFever in 2022 when Bambu Lab was a young company with only one printer line, the X1, to its name. Because Orca was community-driven, it was quick to develop wild new features and offer them to users to test before they were fully stable and corporate-approved. Things like scarf seams, crosshatch infill, mouse ears, and a built-in suite of calibrations were introduced by Orca Slicer first.

Google Preferred Source

Follow Tom's Hardware on Google News, or add us as a preferred source, to get our latest news, analysis, & reviews in your feeds.

Denise Bertacchi
Freelance Reviewer

Denise Bertacchi is a Contributing Writer for Tom’s Hardware US, covering 3D printing. Denise has been crafting with PCs since she discovered Print Shop had clip art on her Apple IIe. She loves reviewing 3D printers because she can mix all her passions: printing, photography, and writing.

  • warezme
    Seems BambuLab has lost its way.
    Reply
  • zdanee
    So, does Bambulab plan to refund every device sold before this change was made public? Because it looks like they came through the window at night and broke the product you paid for.
    Reply
  • edzieba
    It was a death blow to Orca users when Bambu Lab removed direct access to its cloud servers. Unlike other printers, Bambu Lab machines rely on cloud access to support their advanced features like remote monitoring and reading the filament in the AMS.
    Mayor caveat: that only applies IF you send everything through Bambu's cloud servers.

    If instead, you turn on the printers' 'LAN mode' and bypass Bambu's servers, then Orca Slicer continues to work as it always has to this day, with no loss in functionality.

    Use of the Bambu cloud is not mandatory, but if you use their servers it is mandatory to use them with their applications (either Bambu Studio, or Bambu Connect).
    Reply
  • Shiznizzle
    DRM and BIOS locked internet based control to come just to print items now. Watch.

    I cant comment any further as that will delve into the realm of politics.
    Reply
  • frankieXZ
    warezme said:
    Seems BambuLab has lost its way.
    Nah, it's ex-DJI employees. This is expected.

    Close source is the way for them. Especailly if it threatens control over the ecosystem.
    Reply
  • Pegaroo
    You know what to do people, vote with your wallet.
    Reply
  • chaos215bar2
    Seems the author forgot to explain exactly what feature triggered this response from Bambu.

    Nevertheless, this sounds like standard open source intimidation tactics. Bambu used open source software as a core component in their ecosystem, so now of course they're trying to lock it down and threatening developers with expensive lawsuits for doing things that are perfectly legal and violate no licenses.
    Reply
  • PEnns
    Big pockets overwhelm a man (or small business) who cannot afford to defend himself against expensive, elaborate and possibly baseless suit.

    I have watched that movie before, 1000s of times!
    Reply
  • Scott_Tx
    warezme said:
    Seems BambuLab has lost its way.
    They're no Prusa that's for sure. And really every one expects them to just get worse and worse from what we've seen.
    Reply
  • bavor
    Pegaroo said:
    You know what to do people, vote with your wallet.

    They have. Bambu is now the best selling consumer 3D printer company in the world. They surpassed Creality last year.
    Reply