DirectX 10 Shootout: Nvidia vs. ATI

The Graphics Chips Compared

Turbo Cache (Nvidia) and Hyper Memory (ATI) are features that allow the graphics cards to borrow some RAM from system memory. This minimizes the performance impact of enabling FSAA at higher resolutions on cards with less on-board memory. Under XP, video memory can be expanded from 128 MB or 256 MB to 512 MB. Vista always displays an augmented video memory of 1022 MB.

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Nvidia Graphics Cards
Graphics ChipCode NameMemoryHDR-RVertexshader/PixelshaderGPU FrequencyMemory Frequency
Geforce 8800 Ultra OCG80768 MB GDDR3yes4.0660 MHz2300 MHz
Geforce 8800 UltraG80768 MB GDDR3yes4.0612 MHz2160 MHz
Geforce 8800 GTXG80768 MB GDDR3yes4.0576 MHz1800 MHz
Geforce 8800 GTSG80640 MB GDDR3yes4.0500 MHz1600 MHz
Geforce 8800 GTS OCG80320 MB GDDR3yes4.0575 MHz1700 MHz
Geforce 8800 GTSG80320 MB GDDR3yes4.0500 MHz1600 MHz
Geforce 8600 GTSG84512 MB GDDR3yes4.0675 MHz2016 MHz
Geforce 8600 GTSG84256 MB GDDR3yes4.0675 MHz2016 MHz
Geforce 8600 GT OCG84256 MB GDDR3yes4.0580 MHz1600 MHz
Geforce 8500 GT TCG86256/1022 MB DDR2yes4.0459 MHz800 MHz
Geforce 8400 GS TCG86256/1022 MB DDR2yes4.0459 MHz800 MHz
ATI Graphics Cards
Graphics ChipCode NameMemoryHDR-RVertexshader/PixelshaderGPU FrequencyMemory Frequency
Radeon HD2900 XTR600512 MB GDDR3yes4.0743 MHz1656 MHz
Radeon HD2600 XTRV630512 MB GDDR3yes4.0800 MHz1400 MHz
Radeon HD2600 XTRV630256 MB GDDR4yes4.0800 MHz2200 MHz
Radeon HD2600 ProRV630256 MB DDR3yes4.0600 MHz1400 MHz
Radeon HD2400 XT HMRV610128/1022 MB DDR2yes4.0700 MHz800 MHz
Radeon HD2400 Pro HMRV610256/1022 MB DDR2yes4.0525 MHz800 MHz

HDR-R=High Dynamic Range Rendering

SM=Shader Model
Memory Frequency=physical frequency is half of DDR
TC=Turbo Cache
HM=Hyper Memory
OC=Overclocked

Test Setup

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Nvidia Single Graphics Cards, ATI Single and Crossfire Graphics Cards
CPUIntel Core 2 Extreme X6800, 2.93 GHz
FSB1066 MHz
MotherboardIntel D975XBX2
ChipsetIntel 975X
Memory2x1 GByte, Vitesta DDR2 800 4-4-4-12 533 MHz
Hard DriveHitachi 2 x 120 GByte S-ATA, 8 MB Cache
DVDGigabyte GO-D1600C
LANIntel 1000 Pro
AudioIntel High Definition Audio
Power SupplySeasonic M12 600 Watt
Swipe to scroll horizontally
Drivers & Configuration
GraphicsATI Catalyst 7.9Nvidia Forceware 162.22
Opeating SystemWindows Vista Enterprise
DirectX Version10
Chipset Driver IntelIntel 8.2.0.1014
Swipe to scroll horizontally
Test Matrix
ApplicationBenchmarkAnti Aliasing (AA)Anisotropic Filtering (AF)Possible Problems and Settings
BioshockFraps/Rapture-Intro, Plasmid-IntroNo AAGraphics Driver DecidesAF, AA not offered in Game Menu
Company of Heroes v1.70Game BenchmarkApplication DecidesGraphics Driver DecidesAF not offered in Game Menu, -novsync
Lost PlanetFraps/Mission 1Application DecidesApplication DecidesRow 3 - Cell 4
World in ConflictGame Benchmark, Fraps/TutorialApplication DecidesApplication DecidesRow 4 - Cell 4
  • i have and have been using an old ati x800 gt 256 mb ddr3 i can run bioshock at low res this being an old card i got no hope of a successful upgrade from ati
    Reply