• Review

System Builder Marathon: $625 Gaming PC

by
64 Comments

Benchmark Results: Productivity

Applications

Our overclocking efforts shave almost 30 seconds off the time needed to render one 1080p frame in 3ds Max. 

The overclocked January/February PC once again just edges out last month's efforts when applying filters in Photoshop. 

CPU overclocking doesn’t yield huge gains in AVG scans, but we still see the same ranking by clock speeds seen throughout our other applications and encoding tests. 

We get strange results in WinRAR file compression as both our November and January/February Pentium E5200 systems had a much higher reduction of time when overclocked than the two seconds difference seen last month.   

We finish off our application suite with WinZip file compression where the December PC is able to finally post a one second overclocked victory.

Previous Next
Summary
  1. Higher FPS
  2. CPU And Cooler
  3. Motherboard And Memory
  4. Graphics Card And Hard Drive
  5. Case, Power Supply, And Optical Drive
  6. Assembly And Overclocking
  7. Test System Configuration And Benchmarks
  8. Benchmark Results: Crysis And Unreal Tournament 3
  9. Benchmark Results: World In Conflict And Supreme Commander: Forged Alliance
  10. Benchmark Results: Audio/Video Encoding
  11. Benchmark Results: Productivity
  12. Benchmark Results: Synthetics
  13. Power Consumption
  14. Conclusion
About the author
Paul Henningsen
Read more
Create a new thread in the US Reviews comments forum about this subject
This thread is closed for comments
64 comments
Comment from the forums
    Your comment
  • xx12amanxx
    Yeah Games are definatly more GPU bound than CPU bound at this time.But what about the user who decodes? Next month might be a good time to intro the new am3 triple core seeing as its being sodl for around 150$ and has been seen Oced up to 1ghz over stock.
  • Anonymous
    As I read this review I wonder, why this is only server I know that provides such a throughout testing and evaluation of OC benefit...
    *THUMBS UP*
  • nerrawg
    Nice article guys, like how you seem squeeze the value out of the builds, definitely a good choice of build! My only question is one of personal interest, I wonder if disregarding the set price of $625, a crossfire set up of 2 4830s would give more bang for the buck in gaming then 1 4870? Of course as you have shown it would depend on the cpu, I was thinking around 4 Ghz on a dual core and 4 gigs ram. I am wondering because 2 x 4830 can be had for as little as $170-180 now, and thats pretty awesome.
  • nerrawg
    Looking at the "Radeon HD 4830: High-Speed, Cheap CrossFire" article the results look fairly similar to that seen from this build, with maybe some very small gains in Supreme commander and crysis, while World in Conflict appears to due better on this newer january build. However the 4830 CF was on a test bed without an OC'ed cpu and without overclocking the 4830's, hence my curiosity to know if doing this would significantly increase performance and value over the single 4870?
  • StupidRabbit
    great article as always.. but what happened to the international builder marathon?
  • jv_acabal
    $43 difference bang for the buck. How about in the long run? Sure you'll be paying more than 43 bucks for the electricity bill. I think January's build is better. It might be slower than this month's build but is still very playable at most games.
  • maxwellsmart_80
    Why do you keep building the same system (practically) over and over again?

    It would have been awesome to see a system based on the Phenom II X3 "700 Series" at this price point....especially paired w/ the ATI 4830 or 4850. Dont'cha think a 4870 is a tad much for a "$625 system?" - you would have had a "Dragon Platform" - very doable at your price range. You wouldn't have had to do DDR3 either - DDR2 would have worked quite nicely.
  • cangelini
    StupidRabbitgreat article as always.. but what happened to the international builder marathon?


    International competition is in edits--almost ready to go live! Interesting results there, too.
  • Onus
    Excellent article. I think this was a good build.
    That Rosewill case (and all their cheap ones like it) will take a front mounted 120mm fan. You had $6 left over, so it would have fit in your budget.
  • jcknouse
    THG Staff note:Here are links to each of the four articles in this month’s System Builder Marathon...


    I hate being picky...but...

    The links aren't imbedded in those 4 article designations at the top of the article, as of the writing of this note.
  • jcknouse
    My bad...this negative to me...*this* month lol

    Sorry
  • cangelini
    jcknouseI hate being picky...but...The links aren't imbedded in those 4 article designations at the top of the article, as of the writing of this note.


    Because they haven't been published yet ;-)
  • Tedders
    I agree with some of the other posters. I would like to see the SBMs with the new Phenom II. Maybe even some of the new AM3 systems. From what I have read, it can be a little tricky to setup a new AM3 system with the correct processor, motherboard and memory configuration.
  • caamsa
    Ahhh yet another "Intell System Builder Marathon" please call it what it is.
  • Onus
    My present challenge is to come up with a $600 gaming build for a friend, AND the OS must be included in that price (so really a
  • Onus
    caamsaAhhh yet another "Intell System Builder Marathon" please call it what it is.


    Couldn't edit my comment; trying again...

    ...so really a sub-$500 build). I was going to go AMD, but discovered that an Intel 5200 is actually going to be cheaper, unless I give up a lot of performance. So, Caamsa, I expect the SBM articles will continue to use Intel chips at this price point.
  • Tindytim
    jtt283My present challenge is to come up with a $600 gaming build for a friend, AND the OS must be included in that price (so really a

    http://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList.aspx?Submit=ENE&N=2060350368%204027&bop=And&Order=PRICE

    Just cut $100 off for the OS, or go with Ubuntu.
  • allthatjazz
    I still don't see how you can call it a 'System Build' without factoring in the OS! Just call it a $725 build and throw Vista on there, or specify that you're doing an open OS.
  • billiardicus
    Nice Build. A few thoughts for anyone on a budget build:
    1. Don't buy a crappy case. A good case can be used over and over again. You'll upgrade the cpu, gpu, mobo, etc...but you can keep using a case. There's plenty of great $50 cases (Centurion CAC5, Antec 300, etc). Pony up another $25, and get a solid case.

    2. The same applies to the powersupply (Tom's picked a good one).
  • dirtmountain
    Another very good SBM article. Shows what a builder has to do to reach a budget in real life pricing by going with a cheaper case, HSF, CPU to get a higher performance GPU to fit in a build. Good addition with the power consumption charts, i'd have no problem running a quality 430w PSU with this build. I'm interested in seeing an AMD build, perhaps they'll be available for the Feb/Mar SBM articles. Good job and thanks for this great writeup.
Display more comments
Most Popular
  1. Toaster RAID Returns, Better Than Ever
  2. Seagate Releases Firmware to Fix HDD Bricks
  3. Seagate's Update Bricking Working HDDs
The Latest On Tom's Hardware
Edition
Subscribe to our newsletter
Company
Resources
Other Purch sites
  • © 2018 Purch All Rights Reserved.