Dell Shipped Server Motherboards With Spyware

Latest Videos FromTom's Hardware
TOPICS
Marcus Yam served as Tom's Hardware News Director during 2008-2014. He entered tech media in the late 90s and fondly remembers the days when an overclocked Celeron 300A and Voodoo2 SLI comprised a gaming rig with the ultimate street cred.
  • dan117
    FAIL
    Reply
  • back_by_demand
    Epic fail
    Reply
  • halls
    At least they admitted their mistake, and are making it right.
    Reply
  • jazz84
    I'd be curious as to how the spyware even made its way onto the boards to begin with. Sounds like Dell needs to take a closer look at their vendors...

    Then again, this is Dell we're talking about. "Meh, good enough" is practically their corporate policy.
    Reply
  • jazz84
    hallsAt least they admitted their mistake, and are making it right.
    I dunno, this may be too apologist for my taste. Not sure how this is an actual mistake; do they have a pile marked "good" and another marked "inexplicably loaded with malware" in their spares depots? As a couple folks have already pointed out, this simply has "FAIL" written all over it.
    Reply
  • warfart1
    What I want to know is how spyware is running off a motherboard. There is either a dedicated ROM chip for the bot to run off of, or there is an infected BIOS, in either case Dell HAD to know the boards were bad.
    Reply
  • jazz84
    warfart1What I want to know is how spyware is running off a motherboard. There is either a dedicated ROM chip for the bot to run off of, or there is an infected BIOS, in either case Dell HAD to know the boards were bad.
    THIS. Someone has to go out of their way to make something like this happen. For Dell to essentially respond to the issue with, "Whoopsiedaisy, we made a little boo-boo!" is a total side-step. They should be launching a full internal investigation to find the origin of the program(s) as well as how and where the boards were tampered with. Half-arsing it, however, is par for the course for Dell.

    Kinda makes me wonder whatever happened with the investigation into those counterfeit i7s, but that's a question for another thread...
    Reply
  • excalibur1814
    jazz84THIS. Someone has to go out of their way to make something like this happen. For Dell to essentially respond to the issue with, "Whoopsiedaisy, we made a little boo-boo!" is a total side-step. They should be launching a full internal investigation to find the origin of the program(s) as well as how and where the boards were tampered with. Half-arsing it, however, is par for the course for Dell.Kinda makes me wonder whatever happened with the investigation into those counterfeit i7s, but that's a question for another thread...
    Who has told you that they're not investigating this? Why should the results be public? Maybe they will be once they find something.


    Reply
  • sirmorluk
    Who is on the other end of the telemetry feed is what I want to know?
    Where are the boards being manufactured?
    My guess is (speculation only)they are being made in China and this is more than likey a case of international corporate espionage.
    Reply
  • j51
    hallsAt least they admitted their mistake, and are making it right.
    True.... but How long did it take for Dell to admitted this problem?
    Reply