One Last Look: ASRock And MSI Preview P55 Motherboards

Braidwood, RIP

We've seen several motherboard designs with these empty spaces for a slot of some sort. It's no secret that this was to be the basis for Intel's Braidwood technology, essentially the evolutionary update to Turbo Memory functioning akin to an on-board SSD up to 16GB large.

Unfortunately, Braidwood and the pin-compatible big-brother to P55--P57--are no more. The good news for those who were planning to hold off on P55 in anticipation of P57/Braidwood is that you don't have to. The bad news is that we'll never know how well the technology might have performed. Initial reports suggest that it really didn't, though.

Back-Panel I/O

ASRock gives value-seekers a nod with twin legacy PS/2 ports, IDE connectivity, and a floppy connector on-board. The rest of the P55 Deluxe's back-panel is wholly modern, though. Coaxial/optical audio, lots of USB 2.0, eSATA, FireWire 400, twin Gigabit Ethernet controllers, and six 1/8" mini-jacks for analog audio are all made accessible.

Simple, Smart, Inexpensive

Intel is positioning the P55 chipset as a mainstream alternative to the X58-based boards out there today. Thus, it's somewhat strange to us that so many vendors are building high-end P55 platforms that overlap in price with the least-expensive X58 solutions already reviewed. Elaborate voltage regulation, bridge chips, complex cooling--it all seems overkill when you think about the enthusiast who held off on Core i7 for LGA 1366 because he didn't want to pay more than $200 for his motherboard.

That's why we think ASRock is playing things smart here by keeping the price down, even on its highest-end P55 board. Intel's first PCH doesn't need much to keep it cool--it's a 4.7W component, after all. A passive cooler monopolizes minimal board space and costs less than a heatpipe-based solution, but it gets the job done all the same.

We'll be curious to see what the P55 Deluxe sells for on the street, especially if MSI's P55-GD80 is competitive (with its fancier cooling and more overclocking-oriented value-adds).

Plenty Of Power

ASRock went with a 16-phase implementation here, which should be plenty for most air/water overclocking efforts.

On several different occasions, I've sought feedback as to why motherboard manufacturers are engaging in this "phase war," especially with P55, a purportedly mid-range platform. Of course, the answer is different, depending who you ask. According to ASRock, additional phases can help stabilize voltages at light loads. Conversations with Gigabyte suggest that more phases distribute loading more evenly, resulting in a cooler circuit. But Intel's upcoming P55 flagship only employs six power phases, and Intel insists it spent its time optimizing component layout, similarly affecting the thermal impact of its design.

We'll be digging deeper into the truths behind power later. Until then, look forward to the P55 launch early next month--we have tons of coverage planned!

Chris Angelini
Chris Angelini is an Editor Emeritus at Tom's Hardware US. He edits hardware reviews and covers high-profile CPU and GPU launches.
  • apache_lives
    MSI *shudders*
    Reply
  • dingumf
    Yea MSI still isn't a respectable company after what I've seen from the TV tuner I bought from them.
    Reply
  • apache_lives
    dingumfYea MSI still isn't a respectable company after what I've seen from the TV tuner I bought from them.
    ever heard of a Geforce4 Ti4200 overheating? or a cd burner that burns once and requires a reboot to work again? dont get me started on how shoddy there products are.
    Reply
  • JeanLuc
    A Ti4200? That's was launched in 2002, get over it. MSI has some really neat products especially when it comes to motherboards, in fact they currently have the best AM3 board on the market so if there recent success with AMD chipsets can be carried over to Intel chipsets we should see a good range of top quality boards from the launch of P55.
    Reply
  • The_Blood_Raven
    Ever since the P35 MSI has been making some great boards and their GPUs with the aftermarket cooling work very well.
    Reply
  • viometrix
    EVGA ALL THE WAY
    Reply
  • viometrix
    any really good tech enthusiast wouldnt use msi anyways....theyd go with evga, asus, and some supermicro products... msi is just too low end or mainstream for me. being the fact that i ran the rma dept for a computer company i worked for, we had to send msi products back for repair or replacement 5 to 1 versus other products for other manufacturers. so say what you want, i am stating a failure rate that is practical in the industry
    Reply
  • origosis
    I think it makes some sense to put alot of work into the P55 boards. It might make it cost more then the 1366 boards, but people like me like the idea of taking an $80 part and making it run faster then the $600-$900 i7.. Is it possible? I dunno. But if we can spend $200 on a p55 board and spend $50-$200 on an i5 and get it running close to the i7 975... Then that makes sense to have these expensive p55's... a niche? i don't think so. Probably a pretty big crowd these days. Look at how well the AMD's with hidden cores sell.
    Reply
  • apache_lives
    VioMeTriXany really good tech enthusiast wouldnt use msi anyways....theyd go with evga, asus, and some supermicro products... msi is just too low end or mainstream for me. being the fact that i ran the rma dept for a computer company i worked for, we had to send msi products back for repair or replacement 5 to 1 versus other products for other manufacturers. so say what you want, i am stating a failure rate that is practical in the industry
    Exactly right and agree there, and reguardless of trolls voting down facts are facts

    zipzoomflyhighI've used 6 MSI boards and currently have a MSI HD4850. Never had a problem with any of them.
    You either work for MSI or are lucky

    zipzoomflyhighYou recommend EVGA, a company that just started making mobo's a couple years ago over MSI, ROFL.
    ROFL @ MSI being recomended

    As for ASUS - I must have sold atleast 1000 P5GC-MX, P5GC-MX/1333, P5KPL-CM and P5KPL-AMPS over the last few years and only seen ~5 with any issues, for a budget motherboard there second to none, and have a decent Intel chipset.
    Reply
  • meatwad53186
    JeanLucA Ti4200? That's was launched in 2002, get over it. MSI has some really neat products especially when it comes to motherboards, in fact they currently have the best AM3 board on the market so if there recent success with AMD chipsets can be carried over to Intel chipsets we should see a good range of top quality boards from the launch of P55.
    Lol @ "MSI" having the best AM3 board. I'm sure it's not a horrible board, especially for the price, but when a Crosshair III can be had for $35 more or the M4A79T Deluxe for $24 more, why would you even consider the GD70?
    Reply