System Builder Marathon, March 2010: $1,500 Enthusiast PC
CPU, Motherboard, And Cooler
CPU: Intel Core i7 920
Pardon the pun, but Intel's Core i7-920 CPU is at the core of our component selection. We wanted to pit a comparably-priced Core i7 system against the Core i5-750, and when that's the goal, the i7-920 is the only model in the budgetary neighborhood. It was at least a month ago when we selected components for this SBM--now that the Core i7-930 model is available, it would probably have been our pick, but the Core i7-920 remains a fine choice for our purposes.
Read Customer Reviews of Intel's Core i7-920
The comparison between the Core i5-750 and Core i7-920 is very interesting because, from a practical standpoint, the more visible difference between these processors is the Core i7-920’s ability to utilize Hyper-Threading. Both CPUs have four physical cores running at 2.66 GHz at nominal speeds (and 2.8 GHz with all of the cores active), but the Core i7-920 presents eight logical processors to the operating system. Of course, there are many more technical differences than that.
The Lynnfield-based Core i5-750 employs an on-die PCI Express controller limited to 16 lanes of second-generation connectivity. Compare that to the X58 Express chipset's 36 lanes. Also, the Core i7-920 sports a triple-channel memory controller versus Core i5-750's dual-channel logic.
Motherboard: ASRock X58 Extreme
Read Customer Reviews of ASRock's X58 Extreme
Stay On the Cutting Edge: Get the Tom's Hardware Newsletter
Get Tom's Hardware's best news and in-depth reviews, straight to your inbox.
To compete in the same ballpark as Core i5-750, we need an appropriately-priced motherboard, but we don't want to give up any performance, features, or overclocking potential. We want our cake and we want to eat it, too.
Fortunately, my fellow editor Thomas Soderstrom has already done the ground work for us in his sub-$200 Core i7 board roundup. When the dust settled, the ASRock X58 Extreme took the “recommended buy” honor with a combination of great overclocking and performance capabilities and the lowest price. At $160, it's actually $10 cheaper than the Gigabyte P55-UD4P we used in tandem with the Core i5 750 CPU in the previous SBM.
CPU Cooler: Rosewill Fort 120
Read Customer Reviews of Rosewill's Fort 120
Rosewill's FORT 120 has proven itself to be an effective LGA 1366 cooler that can handle the Core i7's massive heat output, but without breaking the bank. At $40 online when this review was written, it's an easy choice for overclockers looking for big performance on a small budget.
Current page: CPU, Motherboard, And Cooler
Prev Page The Components Next Page Video Cards, Power Supply, And Case-
skora I find it funny Cleeve that you mention the effects of ATIs monopoly on the high end GPU market but nothing on the CPU front. How much better off would we all be if AMD had a competing product for the Core i5/7s.Reply
Out of curiosity, how big is the storage capacity needed for your benchmark suit? I know you were over budget, but how close could you have come to one of the lower capacity SSDs and their performance advantages? -
The labels on all the charts appear to be wrong. They're mentioning a "Current $1300 System" but I thought the current system was $1500?Reply
-
anamaniac To be honest, this just somehow seems disappointing to me.Reply
But then I think of how much I spent on my rig, and got less, I'm even more disappointed.
It's crazy that prices keep raising on everything though. 6 months ago I was $9/GB for DDR2, in Canadian dollars. $12.50/GB for DDR3. It's absolutely ridiculous. -
Crashman OtusIt looks like i5->i7 is not worth it for gamers. The increases when FPSReply
I've got news for you: i3->i7 is not worth it for gamers. Tom's Hardware has an interesting article in the works. -
p1n3apqlexpr3ss @CrashmanReply
Sounds good, this something to do with the i3 HTed vs traditional quad thing? -
Crashman p1n3apqlexpr3ss@CrashmanSounds good, this something to do with the i3 HTed vs traditional quad thing?Reply
I think it's a Windows 7 thread shifting and dual-threaded games thing, since both the i3 and i7 have HT. -
Stardude82 SethVNThe labels on all the charts appear to be wrong. They're mentioning a "Current $1300 System" but I thought the current system was $1500?Reply
The whole comparison is BS. $200 is a lot of money where I come from and the stock cooling on the i5 750 is garbage. The low-end Conroes had much better cooling and they were only 65W TDP. I say stick your no-name heatsink on last quarters machine, call it a $1400 box, redo the overclocking and then publish the results as that way they will be at least somewhat relevant.