System Builder Marathon: Sub-$4000 PC

Power Supply: Cooler Master RS-850-EMBA

Cooler Master’s top 850W power supply remains our choice for this System Builder Marathon in spite of severe criticism by several readers. We checked NVidia’s SLI-Approved Lists thoroughly and inspected each of the recommended units, and came to the conclusion that the RS-850-EMBA was unbeatable for its price in our configuration.

Cooler Master RS-850

Helping our selection was the fact that most of NVidia’s choices had significant problems, ranging from the listed power-plug fitment issue (latch too wide to fit into the hole) to user issues with too much power being supplied over a single PCI-Express cable header on modular-cable units. The select few from NVidia’s list that had neither issue were far more expensive than the RS-850-EMBA, yet our experience has shown that our current favorite model has plenty of power to spare.

And experience is what our decision was really about. We’ve heard rumors that Cooler Master used less-reliable suppliers, but those rumors concerned older, lower-rated models. We’ve heard rumors that 850 watts isn’t enough, but our system pulled less than 600 watts under gaming conditions, where graphics power consumption is highest. We’ve heard rumors that there wouldn’t be enough amperage to the 12-volt rails, but our unit’s 720 watts of maximum 12-volt power is far more than even the 600 watts total system power demanded by our configuration.

In other words, we’re completely confident of our selection and have severe doubts about the veracity of claims against the RS-850-EMBA’s adequacy.

Motherboard Cooling : Antec SpotCool

The Asus Striker II Extreme comes equipped with a water block, but this feature is wasted on us. The problem is that water cooling the CPU and Northbridge still leaves a bunch of other components to become unstably hot, including our value-priced RAM. Asus has even included a VRM fan with most of its liquid-cooled-chipset motherboards, but these accessory fans tend to be inefficient and noisy. Our testing has led to a better solution in the Antec SpotCool.

Antec Spotcool Fan

The SpotCool provides excellent airflow at moderate noise levels that are easily dampened by our ATX enclosure, cooling the RAM, chipset, and VRM effectively.

Asus’ inclusion of a water block on the Northbridge is actually a minor drawback for us, because it reduces the sink area normally protecting the chipset. Yet the Antec SpotCool was effective enough to keep our chipset well below 60 degrees Celsius during overclock testing for our upcoming competition, while still providing the additional cooling to other components.

Thomas Soderstrom
Thomas Soderstrom is a Senior Staff Editor at Tom's Hardware US. He tests and reviews cases, cooling, memory and motherboards.
  • L1qu1d
    Good Article, i'd still like to see more current generation games, such as COD4, Bioshock, Grid, Gears of Ware etc, I mean prey is a very old game and warhammer meh...

    Either way very well explained article, but for some1 like me the 8800 Ultras still sell for around 500$ here, and 3 of them would set me back 1500, while the GX2s 1000-1200:P
    Reply
  • Waspy
    Liquid, what was their old rig? Wasn't it 2x 8800GTXes? That pretty much squarely beat 2x 9800GX2s? So you don't need 3, only 2!

    Also, good point, they need to benchmark games like GRID and Age of Conan as well!
    Reply
  • Waspy
    Ahhh too bad about the videocard choice here. I would have liked to see a 2x GTX260 rig...I think that'll be the next power-gamer's rig without dropping the extra $500 on the 2x GTX280 and the extra $300 on a 1wK PSU...although I'm sure this 850W could handle it. I'm going to be running GTX260s on a 750W quality PSU...I predict absolutely no problems.
    Reply
  • mr roboto
    Yes good article but I have to echo the exact sentiment from above. Prey is a fun game but it was never really the system killer to begin with. Some shader intensive games would be nice too.

    I think Nvidia is going to discontinue the 8800GTX\Ultras real soon here. Right now on Newegg.com they don't have any of either card. Over the last few weeks they've been sporadic as far as being in stock. I would consider adding another 8800GTX to my rig but like L1qu!d said they're still pretty expensive. The lowest price I've seen for the 8800GTX's is around $350. If I could find one for $250-$300 range it would be worth it.
    Reply
  • L1qu1d
    Yeah because I kno in certain games tri and quad scale better. Age of Conan, COD4 are some examples:)
    Reply
  • mr roboto
    WaspyI think that'll be the next power-gamer's rig without dropping the extra $500 on the 2x GTX280 and the extra $300 on a 1wK PSU...although I'm sure this 850W could handle it. I'm going to be running GTX260s on a 750W quality PSU...I predict absolutely no problems.
    Are you high? 2 GTX's on an 850w or even a 1KW PSU? With all the other peripherals installed, no way. Asus's new top of the line ARES rig uses 2 1KW PSU's for three GTX 280's. So GTX 260 SLI rig will need a minimum 1KW.
    Reply
  • neodude007
    Nice article guys. Its funny that a $1,200 could beat that $4,000 rig in a lot of games/benchies. My E8400 @ 3.8GHz and SLI 8800GT get around 18,000 3dMark06
    Can't wait to see how the other test builds are going to perform.
    Reply
  • Crashman
    9458565 said:
    Nice article guys. Its funny that a $1,200 could beat that $4,000 rig in a lot of games/benchies. My E8400 @ 3.8GHz and SLI 8800GT get around 18,000 3dMark06
    Can't wait to see how the other test builds are going to perform.

    Of course it beats it in some things, it's overclocked. All the systems will get overclocked on Monday.
    Reply
  • Waspy
    Mr RobotoAre you high? 2 GTX's on an 850w or even a 1KW PSU? With all the other peripherals installed, no way. Asus's new top of the line AREShttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ares rig uses 2 1KW PSU's for three GTX 280's. So GTX 260 SLI rig will need a minimum 1KW.
    Well I was using an instanced case...I'm not going to be running mad-donkey peripherals. Plan is 4 HDDs, 1 DVD burner, 2x GTX260, E8400, bunch of fans and LEDs but those are tiny draws.

    Dude anyways, no, 1kW is overkill. Look at this build! A quality 850W for a water-cooling rig with a QX9650 and 2x 9800GX2s! The GTX260 draws like 10W or more LESS than the 9800GX2, plus I won't be running a quad core OR water cooling. 750W is completely sound. My plan is for this rig to last me until Nehalem so I don't think I'll be going quad core on it etc.
    Reply
  • The_Blood_Raven
    I am shocked, I must give Tom's a hand for this build it was well thought out and they picked the right parts. Only thing I do not like is the TJ09 case, that case does not cooler very well, an Antec 900 beats it with all fans on low, sad. They need to drop the TJ09, I had one and returned it, because it's cooling performance was not great, for a $4k gaming rig you need GREAT cooling. The Cosmos S is not much better, but there are so many other cases on the market that could fit that cooling system in that are a lot better and much cheaper. Oh well, besides the case GOOD JOB THW!
    Reply