Download the Tom's Hardware App from the App Store
The reference for current tech news
Yes No
Ads

Ubisoft Director: Piracy is Killing PC Gaming

by - source: Tom's Hardware

Gamers will never hear the end of developers and publishers crying that pirates are killing PC gaming sales.

It’s true: the subject has been beaten down to the point where it probably does turn away avid gamers from PC versions simply by the thought of it. With the endless war between creator, publisher and stealer ensuing in earnest, honest consumers either are left to deal with the side effects of anti-piracy embedding itself on their PCs, or suffer from a market that seems to get more scarce at the turn of each month.

Recently Ubisoft Shanghai creative director Michael de Plater fired off his mouth to VG247, all hot under the collar and pointing the death of PC gaming towards the pirates who leech from the industry. He said that the PC version of Tom Clancy’s EndWar would have shipped with the console versions had pirating not been an issue.

“To be honest, if PC wasn’t pirated to hell and back, there’d probably be a PC version coming out the same day as the other two,” he told the website. “But at the moment, if you release the PC version, essentially what you’re doing is letting people have a free version that they rip off instead of a purchased version. Piracy’s basically killing PC.”

Although the PC version will likely ship later on, he seemed rather reluctant to mention that a release date even existed. But his words ring true, echoing the overall attitude towards PC gaming by developers and publishers alike.

In a recent interview with Tom Ohle of CD Projekt (formerly with BioWare before taking on The Witcher), he stressed that perhaps developers and publishers should focus on making great games that people will actually buy rather than worry about pirates. "Everything gets pirated, so it’s not limited to PC gaming," he told Tom’s Games earlier this year. "But really, you just want to put out a game that’s solid for your platform. If you’re making a PC game, make a great PC game and people will buy it. I don’t know of any pirates that buy games. They all seem to be pirates for life, y’know? So why fight it? Just make a good game that people want to pay for."

The problem now is that PC games are becoming the minority of the industry. Recently Wal-Mart scaled back its PC software stock altogether, and retail outlets such as GameStop and EB Games have limited the offerings to just a few racks. Already it seems like the PC market is steadily going down hill, and with anti-piracy software sneaking its way on consumers’ PCs as seen with the recently released Spore, gamers who once delighted in picking up a PC game might look towards the Xbox 360 or PlayStation 3 consoles instead

Yes, it’s the same old speech: tired, worn out and ready to be put out to pasture. It will continue to be in the forefront of PC gaming until the issue is resolved, whether publishers give up on the genre altogether or something is devised that will make everyone happy. Until then, PC gamers will have to dig in and wait out the storm.

Share:
82
Comments
X
Submit

Comments
Add your comment
Anonymous 10/09/2008 12:33 PM
Hide
-20+

What really kills PC Gaming is paranoid anti-piracy practices like SecuRom. These malware garbage make life complicated and difficult for legitimate users. I have personally bought only original games up to the day I encountered securom in one of them. I was then forced to download a crack to be able to play my original game !!!! Since them i buy pirated copies for all securom games and buy originals without securom. As you can see securom forces legitimate users to abandon original software because it doesnt work!!!

Look at Stardock entertainment. They are succesful and extremely profitable and they dont lock their games because they know it is pointless. Galactic Civilizations and Sins of a solar Empire sell like hotcakes.

Conclusions: Companies want to stop you from loaning your game to your friends or reselling it. That is why they use garbage like securom. If piracy was killing PC software Stardock would be broke.

ThePatriot 10/09/2008 12:41 PM
Hide
-4+

Last time I looked PC games sales were up... what gives?

The_Blood_Raven 10/09/2008 12:45 PM
Hide
-9+

So 20% of the people who play their games have pirated copies... Yeah that's whats killing PC gaming, not the prices of hardware, inexperience with hardware which result in expensive Geek Squad visits, and the hassle of installing games on a computer. No it is piracy. Developers just can't cope with losing a fifth of their potential customers!

To be honest, how many of those pirates would buy the game if it were not for piracy, probably very few. Piracy is not the issue, it is hard to compete with consoles when PC gaming requires so much more knowledge and experience to use. You don't need to install patches, update drivers, tweak display and audio settings, or deal with DRMs with consoles. PC gaming is dying thanks to the lack of innovation, high price of gaming PCs, the work put into maintaining the PC and game, and the lack of community with the PC. Sorry Ubisoft, but you need shut the hell up, afterall Ubisoft makes some of the most glitchy and broken PC titles out there. That might be a problem.

noobe1981 10/09/2008 1:04 PM
Hide
-1+

Hey ubi morons. You do realize consoles games get pirated just as fast right? And that most pirated games can't be pirated for multiplayer only single player. HINT HINT!

johnyeah 10/09/2008 1:08 PM
Hide
-2+

Being able to just put in the Blu-ray in the PS3 or the DVD in the WII and just play without having to install simply makes console games more appealing to the average Joe than PC games.

I don't pirate games. However, at this point in my life I find that I'm not that fond of PC games as I was back in my high school and college years. I bought TF2 and COD4 because they're great games and props to Steam for being one of the best platforms for buying games. I won't be buying Crysis because of its ridiculous hardware demands and SecuRom. I refuse to be the one stuck in the middle of the fight between the stupid software publishers and pirates.

Yuka 10/09/2008 1:29 PM
Hide
-2+

A great game will still sell, that's a fact; I totally agree with Tom Ohle on that. Pirates, usually love free software and belive in that, so they crack games for other people. They are some kind of "Robin Hoods" under that scope IMO.

Anyway, reasons aside, they do hurt the PC software business, but software makers are taking it easy blaming piracy and not thinking about their crappy releases and/or boggus releases. Also, they use such stupid DRM methods thet you start to think: "they deserve it for being such lazy people". CEO's of those companies should start analyzing and think about others ways to make a profit! Google has taken a step forward in that matter, i hope it works fine.

Esop!

randomizer 10/09/2008 1:32 PM
Hide
-1+

A Cevat Yerli clone is now at Ubisoft.

hemelskonijn 10/09/2008 1:56 PM
Show
jaragon13 10/09/2008 1:57 PM
Hide
-3+

What a load,I quit buying Ubisoft games TWO YEARS AGO because of their shitty ass "Tom Clancy" games.
MAYBE if they start making real titles that people give two shits about,then they might quit beaching about Piracy.
Also,Piracy IS more rampant on consoles,maybe the dumb fucks don't realize it because there's no serial key or what nonsense.
I also don't play Call Of Duty 4 anymore because of the retarded anti-piracy measures which has RESET my character(level 55 twice) three times.No support from them.

Anonymous 10/09/2008 2:02 PM
Hide
-7+

The problem is the gaming industry is stalled. All the good games only get released on consoles. It's the chicken and the egg all over again. They blame the pirates and move to the consoles, we get b games and refuse to pay the A price for B games.

Really where are all these good games. And if you really want to, you can always make systems that will make players buy games. MMO's for example are mostly bought, most of blizzards games go skyrocket. Guess why no one wants to buy the newest C&C? It's not because it's so fun. Fifa 2009? What's the difference? A small new interface, even worst to control your toon? I love 96 and if I would buy one, I'd buy the simple one.

Good games are no longer on the PC and that's part of the problem. Why pay premium prices for bad games?

Anonymous 10/09/2008 2:11 PM
Hide
-6+

All game studios whine about piracy. Beside Valve with its Steam system, I haven't seen a studio coming up with its own solution that tries to stop piracy. Relying on 3rd party things to solve your problems is clearly not working (it's only your game that ends in torrents/P2P networks, not the DRM protection used to stop (?) piracy). Show me that you at least tried something on your own to stop piracy (an in-house solution - invested your profits into something you thought about, not a product you bought because the seller told you "this will stop piracy, guaranteed"), and then go and say to the public "we are too stupid, we can't stop pirates" and stuff like that.

tomasf 10/09/2008 2:14 PM
Hide
-6+

and what about console games piracy???? don't be fool, the console games piracy is even bigger than pc games piracy

Milany 10/09/2008 2:22 PM
Show
Anonymous 10/09/2008 2:31 PM
Hide
-4+

So, tell me, Mr. Ubisoft Director. When console piracy will reach current PC piracy levels, what will you say? Stop taking the easy way out ("we will release no PC titles due to piracy") and do (or pretend to do) something about the piracy. If the profit is not that great, then you obviously chose the wrong way to do the business.

aznguy0028 10/09/2008 2:32 PM
Hide
-6+

yea, but they are turning a blind eye to console pirating and solely using PC gamers as a scapegoat. a few years back i moved from console gaming to PC gaming, and this is where i'll take my stand. PC games imo, are far more superior and fun compared to consoles, i am sad that they are solely blaming PC piracy instead of piracy across all platforms as an issue.

future games that i'll be buying and supporting when i could easily pirate, would be Call of Duty 5, Street Fighter IV, Starcraft 2, Diablo 3.

Ubi Soft(Sux), make games of those caliber, and i will gladly buy your product. Comparing tom clancy games to games such as COD4, is like night and day, obviously the choice is clear.

stemnin 10/09/2008 2:34 PM
Hide
-2+

Ubi makes console games, I never like Prince of Persia (played on console), the only game i've ever bought from them was Far Cry (only published by them), and will probably get Far Cry 2 (developer and publisher).

badboy4dee 10/09/2008 2:34 PM
Hide
-1+

Don't give us dat CR@P nubisoft! Wanna talk about losing revenue to piracy?? Buttholes! How bout stopping your own in house piracy called the....CEO, exec's,vp,svp etc... Duhhh. How much are they raping your company for?? MILLIONS You fargin iceholes. Nubisoft u suk, your games suk and you pay your higher ups wayyyyyyy to much $$ to be telling us your losing money to piracy. SO STFU

TSM

barbos 10/09/2008 2:50 PM
Hide
-7+

Horrible buggy releases for the new rehashes of the same game is what is killing PC sales. They have saturated the market with the same crap over and over again and wonder why sales are drying up...

Sadly, most games have patches out within 3 days of release date and continue to fix major bugs even a year later after release. If it wasn't for greedy publishers pushing out half-finished games before they are ready, maybe people would buy them. But when people spend $50 for a game that won't even work on their system, they often get upset with the company and stop buying their products.

Blame the publishers, developers, and poor marketing.

Anonymous 10/09/2008 3:05 PM
Hide
-5+

Pirated version of Fallout3 is already available to download, while PC version is not.
Ubisoft really talks nonsense here - platform doesn't matter for pirates

neiroatopelcc 10/09/2008 3:06 PM
Hide
-2+

"If you’re making a PC game, make a great PC game and people will buy it." -- completely right this part!
If we scroll back the time 10 years I would consider myself mad if I would buy more than one game a year, yet wouldn't hesitate to aquire one of the collections of cd's that 'private publishers' were distributing for a fee equal to a game in price. The reason being, that most games I tried weren't very much my liking, and I'd hate wasting my money on a game I didn't like.
Fast forward to now. I may still not have a license for each and every piece of software on my pc, but I'm an active customer @ play.com and even went to brick and mortar stores to buy games I liked. Mind you I had the razor 1911 version of crysis weeks before the original, but I actually bought the original. Something I wouldn't have done if I couldn't have tried it out first. Just this month I bought civ4: colonization on eurogamer @ £19 or what it was set at. Not because I couldn't pirate it, but because I knew the old one from my teenage years, and knew I wouldn't regret buying it. (didn't know about the tutorial issues at the time)

In short - while piracy accounts for a huge load of software on people's pc's it ain't all bad. Cause most of that software would've never been bought by the people who have it anyway. It's not that people can't afford to buy it, it's simply that they won't buy something where value and price don't match. And the only way to find out, is by using the retail version. Demos are often very different from the retail version, be it games or productivity software.
(just think trial account in wow, or need for speed demo for carbon).

On a side note - I'm not aware of any of my aquantances who has a playstation or xbox that isn't modded to run pirates games. So while piracy on pc's might be an issue, it isn't the only one.

The main issue is the low quality of software released. Higher quality equals more happy users, and a higher share of legit users.

Anonymous 10/09/2008 3:09 PM
Hide
-5+

pirated fallout3 version for xbox is already out,
PC is still to be seen.

platform doesn't matter for pirates

t85us 10/09/2008 3:28 PM
Hide
--2+

games are much toooo expen$ive...

barbos 10/09/2008 3:43 PM
Hide
-2+

neiroatopelcc also hits on another good point. For some reason they feel every pirated copy equals one lost sale, but as he mentions, some people pirate software simply because they would never buy it anyway. In that case they aren't losing money because they still wouldn't get a sale, the pirate would just not be able to play the game.

lambofgode3x 10/09/2008 3:57 PM
Hide
-1+

i totally agree with these posts. games for pc suck now. there are some great games that come out, but thats rare. and i'm sorry but i'm not spending half of my monthly insurance payment on a fucking game. you want me to buy it? put out a good game and dont charge 50-60 dollars for it.

fyi, there are companies whose entire purpose is to charge end users for installing mod chips in their xbox, ps3, etc.

lambofgode3x 10/09/2008 4:01 PM
Hide
-3+

also, game companies want games to sell...how about they dont release bullshit titles like PDC World Championship Darts 2008. you're going to sell what, 12 copies? jackasses....

hemelskonijn 10/09/2008 4:20 PM
Hide
-1+

@Milany:

In the Netherlands is every copy legal due to the fact that we pay a copyright license fee when buying Writable CD’s. The fee is only E0,50 cents.

This is is truth multimedia including but not limited to audio, video photo's and books for the purpose off education and or home usage.
Software however is never legally copied partly because software developers and publishers don`t get a a share of the 50cent tax and partly because even if they did get some money for it they have security wich has to be broken or worked around wich in turn is illegal.

The same goes for downloading ... downloading of pirated software is illegal to make things worse even if you use your bought key or license file.
Audio video books and pictures on the other hand are legal to download to copy and even to share among friends (not mass distribution and not for a fee) uploading however is illegal even though you pay the tax since your mass distributing it and most p2p protocols networks and clients upload while downloading.

back to the topic:
i strongly disagree with the people who say there are less good games coming out for the pc in contrast to the consoles.
In my opinion ports are the main reason the consoles seem to have the better games since the few titles that are exclusive to a console most of the time are the better games.

Milany 10/09/2008 4:33 PM
Hide
-0+

One more thing I just came up with is this.

PC gamers are gamers that want to get the best visuals and performance out of their games. But because of the fact that PC’s are more advanced then game consoles are the games never the less the same and get PC games less visual quality and sparkles because the game consoles cant coop with those high graphical levels.

PC games are to low in quality to play on a high performance PC, so why bother paying for those games.

GenKhan2 10/09/2008 4:38 PM
Hide
-3+

I have been an avid PC gamer for over a decade. I still haven't bought a single game for my launch PS3 but I've bought many PC titles over the same period. Recent anti-piracy efforts by misguided publishers have placed me in a difficult position. When I have to download a pirated copy or crack in order to get the best experience from my purchased game we have serious issues in the PC market. What sells PC is high quality visuals, true multifunction (web/office/game), and the fact it is an open system. Trying to consolize PCs with hardcore DRM will ALWAYS hurt the PC platform because it seeks to eliminate one of the selling points. Wake up publishers. Treat your customers as friends and they will return the favor.

Anonymous 10/09/2008 4:42 PM
Hide
-5+

The problem isn't piracy. It is the lack of good games. I buy all the games I really enjoy playing, but what's the point of spending $40-50 on something you are really only going to enjoy for a week?

Also any game that has a good multiplayer cannot be pirated (basically all Blizzard games).

And finally, I'm tired with all the fucking console ports that just don't feel right on a PC. Game makers save themselves the work, and just port it, the controls and feel are wrong, and no one buys it, and then they blame piracy. If you want to sell PC games, MAKE PC GAMES. Stop trying to sell console ports as PC games.

Anonymous 10/09/2008 5:31 PM
Hide
-0+

Who buys boxed versions of games anymore anyway. You can pay and download them via EA games or Direct2drive which is way better. Just burn or keep a copy of the download and keys on your pc and you're good. I've bought my last 10 games online by download which takes a few hours in the comfort of my own home. Never again will I buy a boxed version. So, who cares if EB games or Walmart reduce shelf space for games, it's an obsolete mode of delivery anyway.

dgrambo 10/09/2008 5:32 PM
Hide
-2+

Why work on a clean title for PC when you can make more money working on a console version and perhaps later port it over to PC (if it looks money). The problem is public opinion. How do you turn your backs on the less profitable customer base in order to focus entirely on the stronger profit center? Well, nows is the right time to blame the consumer and maximize profit! Are you suprised? Its just bu$ine$$. Do you believe the CEO's care about anything more than numbers? Do you think the dev teams control the industry? There is is nothing unless its profitable and then more profitable or abandoned. And if you ever try to circumvent the corporation will buy you or litigate you to death. Money is power, power is corruption. What they dont no is corruption leads to revolution and you cant package that.


Ads

Best offers

Newsletters


OK
Ads