Prisoner laments reliance on floppy disks for appeals documents, limiting file sizes to 1.44 MB — prisoners allowed 20 floppy disks in cell, but USB flash sticks are banned in New Jersey system

Several old floppy disks
(Image credit: Future)

A prisoner incarcerated at the New Jersey State Prison has written about the trials and tribulations of corresponding with his legal representatives while being shackled by ancient computer technology. Namely, floppy diskettes.

Jorge Luis Alvarado, writing for the PJP (Prison Journalism Project), says it is difficult to keep abreast of developments in his case due to a prison-imposed digital divide. Alvarado’s lawyers send documents on flash drives, which must be decanted to (sometimes multiple) floppy disks on a special computer in the law library. Getting library computer access can take days, and time can be crucial during legal appeals.

We’d say the general public’s use of USB flash drive technology became mainstream 20 years ago. Their ascendancy neatly crosses over the removal of the humble floppy drive as a standard component of a pre-built PC.

Moreover, any advantages USB flash drives had over floppies 20 years ago have scaled dizzyingly new heights of usability. Now flash drives are faster, more capacious, and extremely affordable. They are even sold in multipacks – not quite up to a common 50x or 100x pack like floppy disks, but people don’t need so many.

Capacity and reliability woes

Alvarado underlines the issues with floppy disks in 2025 from his personal point of view. “A single legal brief can easily take up the memory of two floppy disks,” he complains. Remember, PC HD floppy disk capacity was only up to 1.44MB. For better capacity removables in the floppy era, you would have to invest in more expensive media like Zip disks or SyQuests. The great home PC CD writing boom would occur around the year 2000.

Another issue Alvarado has with floppies is that “floppy disks also get corrupted easily.” Lessons learned the hard way mean prisoners will need to make backups among their limited floppy disk supplies. The PJP author also notes that floppies are inherently circling the plughole, as no company has been producing new media since 2011. Indeed, Sony shut down its floppy production lines in that year.

Some will argue that prisons shouldn’t have all the latest computer technologies available to inmates. However, that has to be balanced by allowing those behind bars sufficient resources to advocate for their freedom. Some studies suggest that between 4 and 6% of those incarcerated in US prisons are innocent.

Follow Tom's Hardware on Google News to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button.

Mark Tyson
News Editor

Mark Tyson is a news editor at Tom's Hardware. He enjoys covering the full breadth of PC tech; from business and semiconductor design to products approaching the edge of reason.

  • Pierce2623
    Only 4%? When I got arrested everybody there said they were innocent
    Reply
  • palladin9479
    The probability of anyone having never committed a crime is practically 0. Due purely to the ridiculous number of federal, state and local laws and regulations.

    Thus the whole adversarial jury system.
    Reply
  • gggplaya
    At least let them use ZIP drives. That's what we used in college, all the lab computers had zip drives. Allow inmates to have 2 drives, one for backup and one to transfer to their lawyers.

    I had 100MB zip disks, but the later years went up to 750MB. Plenty enough for all their documents.

    But really the prison should have a closed internal network with a NAS. Give each innmate a few GB of storage for their documents in the library they want to save.
    Reply
  • TechieTwo
    Maybe next time don't commit a crime and floppy disks won't be an issue. Just a thought... ;)
    Reply
  • 8086
    gggplaya said:
    At least let them use ZIP drives. That's what we used in college, all the lab computers had zip drives. Allow inmates to have 2 drives, one for backup and one to transfer to their lawyers.

    I had 100MB zip disks, but the later years went up to 750MB. Plenty enough for all their documents.

    But really the prison should have a closed internal network with a NAS. Give each innmate a few GB of storage for their documents in the library they want to save.
    Skip that idea. Just give them some DVD-RAM discs, drag and drop like a floppy or usb drive with no formatting needed.

    Or how about this far fetched idea: A closed network (intranet) with no internet access and a prisoner login for just their case files.
    Reply
  • Why_Me
    TechieTwo said:
    Maybe next time don't commit a crime and floppy disks won't be an issue. Just a thought... ;)
    Not all incarcerated people are guilty.
    Reply
  • gggplaya
    8086 said:
    Skip that idea. Just give them some DVD-RAM discs, drag and drop like a floppy or usb drive with no formatting needed.

    Or how about this far fetched idea: A closed network (intranet) with no internet access and a prisoner login for just their case files.

    I thought about that and there's no way. CD/DVD's are too easy to break and turn into a slicing device.
    Reply
  • jg.millirem
    TechieTwo said:
    Maybe next time don't commit a crime and floppy disks won't be an issue. Just a thought... ;)
    Maybe next time learn something about the depravities of the US’s carceral system. This article is a clue. 🙄
    Reply
  • Humanearthling
    Flash drives are safer for prisons because I think floppy disks could be formed into tools or weapons more easily.
    Reply