Norwegian gov't consumer watchdog calls out ‘enshittification’ of video games, connected devices, and others — claims hardware deliberately degraded after purchase

An official render of the Canon i-Sensys MF750, one of the printers impacted by these vulnerabilities.
(Image credit: Canon Europe)

Norway's Forbrukerrådet, the government-funded Norwegian Consumer Council, published an 80-page report on February 27, arguing that companies across the tech industry are systematically degrading hardware and software after the point of sale to extract additional revenue from locked-in consumers. The report, titled "Breaking Free: Pathways to a Fair Technological Future," singles out connected devices, printers, video games, and cars as categories where the practice is most acute.

The report refers to this practice as “enshittification,” a gradual, three-stage process in which a company initially attracts users with a genuinely useful service, then degrades that service to benefit business customers, and finally squeezes both groups to maximize returns for shareholders. According to the Forbrukerrådet, digital products are uniquely vulnerable to this cycle because manufacturers can alter them remotely after purchase through software updates. Below, you can see a video the group created about the issue as well.

Latest Videos FromTom's Hardware
TOPICS
Luke James
Contributor

Luke James is a freelance writer and journalist.  Although his background is in legal, he has a personal interest in all things tech, especially hardware and microelectronics, and anything regulatory. 

  • -Fran-
    This gets the message across rather well, but I'm sure it'll be ignored by the people that needs to watch and understand it the most.

    Regards.
    Reply
  • TechieTwo
    You mean financially greedy companies would exploit consumers because government fails to protect them from unscrupulous leches?
    Reply
  • Sippincider
    Companies can degrade the functionality of your car or effectively destroy your connected washing machine with a software update
    Then there's the matter of getting updates.

    My devices of at least the past 15 years were all replaced because they no longer got security updates. All worked perfectly otherwise, many are still in use today but repurposed for offline use.
    Reply
  • PEnns
    Wow!! There are still civilized governments that want to protect their population from Big Biz nefarious scams!! Many other countries are busy dismantling those protective laws and agencies.

    Nah, just kidding, only the US is doing the dismantling!
    Reply
  • SomeoneElse23
    You can't legislate morality.
    Reply
  • thisisaname
    The water companies have been doing this to our rivers and lakes for years.
    Reply
  • Brakheart
    Are these people just now discovering planned obsolescence???
    Reply
  • Thunder64
    Ah yes printer cartridges. I remember my mom trying to print a document and it printed a blank page. I printed a printer status or test page or something from the printer itself and it printed, in the same black ink it refused to print in for anything else. That's a real crappy move HP.

    I just saw on youtube Ford has made accessing the "frunk" on the Mustang Mach E an upcharge otherwise it will be sealed shut. People need to stand up to this.
    Reply
  • nichbal
    Reminds me of my Epson printer. First update after the first year of owning and after the warranty rani out, it bricked itself.

    Bought a new wireless card for it, still nothing. Plugged it directly into my printer, again nothing. Pulled out a voltage tester and no power to the wireless card or cable port.

    Looked online and found out many people had the same thing happen. One person looked at the code of the update and it included a kill command that disabled all print functions except copy. Real crappy move indeed
    Reply
  • alan.campbell99
    To paraphrase The Oatmeal who touched in printers a few years ago; sure the printer is cheap but the official ink you have to use is made from unicorns. Having a device you bought get remotely bricked or subscribing to use something on your gorram car is peak enshittification or close to it.
    Reply