Southbridge Battle: 780a, ICH10 and SB750, Compared
Benchmark Results: Bandwidth And Streaming
Here are the bottlenecks: the fastest integrated storage controller in terms of bandwidth is Intel’s ICH10R, which goes up to 688 MB/s in RAID 5 and 616 MB/s in RAID 0. However, LSI proves its MegaRAID SAS9260-8i as the superior product, delivering more than 1 GB/s on only six Intel X25-E SSDs.
However, our streaming tests delivered higher throughput than the bandwidth numbers would allow, so please take the interface benchmark with a grain of salt, since we don’t know the reason for this behavior.
At peak throughput, LSI’s controller wins again, reaching an outstanding 922 MB/s in RAID 0 and 761 MB/s in RAID 5. The others are all slower at peak throughput, but no solution falls below 520 MB/s (AMD 780a in RAID 5) except when running in degraded mode.
Oops! Write performance is a significant issue on the AMD and Nvidia systems in RAID 5 and in degraded mode. RAID 5 write throughput is down to 77 MB/s on Nvidia’s 780a SLI MCP and to 186 MB/s on the AMD SB750. Intel can maintain 440 MB/s, and you need a professional RAID card such as LSI’s to deliver fast 511 MB/s, even for RAID 5 writes.
This performance issue grows worse when a drive fails. In the case of a degraded array, all solutions drop to performance numbers that are much slower than an indiviudual, single 7,200 RPM drive would otherwise be. AMD and Intel write at extremely poor speeds: 29 and 28 MB/s, respectively. Nvidia at least maintaints its regular RAID 5 performance at 78 MB/s. That’s not fast, but at least it’s something.
LSI scores again thanks to its 512 MB DDR2-800 cache memory, which buffers lots of data even when the array is crippled.
Stay on the Cutting Edge
Join the experts who read Tom's Hardware for the inside track on enthusiast PC tech news — and have for over 25 years. We'll send breaking news and in-depth reviews of CPUs, GPUs, AI, maker hardware and more straight to your inbox.
Current page: Benchmark Results: Bandwidth And Streaming
Prev Page Benchmark Results: I/O Performance Next Page Benchmark Results: Read/Write Throughput