Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in

Op-Ed: Comcast Trying to Prove It Isn't Horrible By Offering Free Internet and Debt Pardon

By - Source: MarketWatch.com | B 26 comments

Comcast's new announcement may look very generous on the surface, but there may be more to it. Read on to find out more.

The cable company Comcast has been under a lot of fire recently. Many folks have called the company 'horrible' and 'pure evil,' among other things. Of course, Comcast's PR team is probably working very hard to prove that it is not a horrible company, and in serving that effort, Comcast has now announced a number of changes to its Internet Essentials program.

The Internet Essentials program is aimed squarely at low-income families, with the idea being to connect as many people as possible to the Internet. For $10 (+VAT) per month, users will have basic Internet access along with the option of purchasing a computer for $150. However, the requirements are strict and clear. You need to be in an area where Comcast offers its service, you may not have subscribed to Comcast Internet service in the last 90 days, you can have no outstanding bills or equipment returns, and most notably, you must have at least one child eligible to participate in the National School Lunch Program. The Internet Essentials program has been running since 2011, and has connected over 350,000 households in that time.

Mind you, those were the old requirements and services. Comcast is temporarily offering up to six months of free service, along with an amnesty program. The amnesty program will officially pardon families signing up who have outstanding bills to Comcast that are over one year old. This loosens up the requirements a bit and will allow more families to sign up. To qualify for the six free months of service, though, you may not have been subscribed to the Internet Essentials program in the past.

Credit should be given where credit is due. Such a program does help a lot of people and makes it possible for many to connect to the world wide web from home who would otherwise never be able to afford it. It is widely known that internet connectivity is quite expensive in the states. The requirements for the program might be strict, but they do ensure that the program is used exclusively by the people who need it the most: today's pupils.

Of course, this program is funded partially through subsidies, which makes us wonder whether there isn't another side to this move. Under these temporary terms, a lot of families that previously couldn't qualify are now able to sign up. The problem is, they might not be able to afford the service after the six-month period is over, yet they could still be tied to an agreement. Ten dollars might not sound like much, but $120 per year is still a big sum of money for some. So the big question is: Is Comcast attempting to reel in more subscribers (who might not even be able to afford the service), simply to raise more subsidy money for themselves? There may not be all that many folks who owe large outstanding payments that are over a year old to Comcast, and accepting $60 less per new family that signs up isn't all that much money for such a big company. From a business point of view, that would make this a fairly cheap, if not profitable, PR stunt.

We find it hard to argue with the fact that this is a good deal for most relevant customers, and we agree that the Internet Essentials program itself is necessary. However, this move has us wondering whether if there are ulterior business motives. The problem isn't that Comcast is using this to make a bigger profit. No, the problem is that to do so, the company is using people's debt to Comcast, to tempt them to get a service they otherwise wouldn't sign up for, and cannot afford.

Topping it all off, Davin Cohen, Executive Vice President and Chief Diversity Officer in Community Investment said "Also, with the recent announcement of our merger with Time Warner Cable, we see a tremendous opportunity to bring the benefits of Internet Essentials to millions of additional families in cities like New York, Los Angeles, Dallas, Kansas City, and Charlotte, to name just a few. I’m thrilled that, after the Time Warner Cable transaction closes, Internet Essentials will be available in nineteen of our nation’s twenty largest cities." This sounds good, but not everyone in the public is entirely comfortable with this merger, and perhaps Comcast is just greasing the wheels to make it as painless as possible for regulators to sign off on it. Comcast is being watched very closely by U.S. antitrust regulators.

For the most part, the Internet Essentials program is good, but it's not all ribbons and gifts. We should be careful, and not get blinded by the cloud of PR smoke. What do you think?

The offer will run until September 20, 2014.

*Any opinions that may or may not be deduced from this article are those of the author, and are not necessarily shared by the rest of Tom's Hardware.

Follow Niels Broekhuijsen @NBroekhuijsen. Follow us @tomshardware, on Facebook and on Google+.


Discuss
Ask a Category Expert

Create a new thread in the News comments forum about this subject

Example: Notebook, Android, SSD hard drive

This thread is closed for comments
Top Comments
  • 14 Hide
    joaompp , August 4, 2014 7:21 PM
    Quote:
    I find the headline and the premise of the article to be hateful.


    You're absolutely right, the Headline should read:
    "ComCast plans to use government subsidies to exploit impoverished families, promises to bring abuse to areas served by TWC once merger is complete"

Other Comments
  • 2 Hide
    clonazepam , August 4, 2014 6:25 PM
    I think they want to get their claws in you now, to be exploited at a later date.
  • 6 Hide
    derekullo , August 4, 2014 6:28 PM
    Here's the plan. We get the warhead and hold the world ransom for 100 megabits.
  • Display all 26 comments.
  • 7 Hide
    Stryter , August 4, 2014 7:21 PM
    Quote:
    Here's the plan. We get the warhead and hold the world ransom for 100 megabits.


    Don't you think we should ask for *more* than a hundred megabits? A hundred megabits isn't exactly a lot of bandwidth these days. Virtucon alone uses over nine gigabits of bandwidth!
  • 14 Hide
    joaompp , August 4, 2014 7:21 PM
    Quote:
    I find the headline and the premise of the article to be hateful.


    You're absolutely right, the Headline should read:
    "ComCast plans to use government subsidies to exploit impoverished families, promises to bring abuse to areas served by TWC once merger is complete"

  • -2 Hide
    bebangs , August 4, 2014 7:30 PM
    Being that we are the number one-provider of Internet and TV service in the entire country, why is it that you aren't wanting to have the number-one Internet service, number-one TV service available? I'm just trying to figure out what it is about Comcast service that you aren't liking, that you aren't wanting to keep. What is it about that service?
    --http://goo.gl/eHGLm5
  • 4 Hide
    knowom , August 4, 2014 7:31 PM
    Yawn a shark wearing a dress is still a shark and a bear with a cute sweater on is still a bear and it ain't no teddy bear despite what Annie may say about Tibbers.
  • 3 Hide
    knowom , August 4, 2014 7:43 PM
    This is nothing, but smoke and mirrors all the stipulations just hammer home that point. What next a discount to coma patients? How cute and considerate Comcast!

    This is evil 101 enslave the majority while presenting yourself as sympathetic kind and humane person to the most vulnerable demographic.
  • 2 Hide
    knowom , August 4, 2014 7:50 PM
    "you must have at least one child eligible to participate in the National School Lunch Program."

    Since that's exactly the type of family that has $10's a month to spare for cable internet and can optionally pull $150's out of their @$$ for a computer as well.

    This is just proof enough that Comcast is defiantly on bath salts.
  • -3 Hide
    damric , August 4, 2014 8:01 PM
    God Bless America.

    Now I have Obamanet to go with my Obamaphone, Obamacare, Obamastamps, and Obamafare.
  • 0 Hide
    MasterMace , August 4, 2014 8:13 PM
    There is no VAT in America. That's Europe only.
  • 0 Hide
    kadesh83 , August 4, 2014 9:20 PM
    Quote:
    God Bless America.

    Now I have Obamanet to go with my Obamaphone, Obamacare, Obamastamps, and Obamafare.


    That is just horribly ignorant of you to say.
  • 0 Hide
    damric , August 4, 2014 9:46 PM
    Quote:
    Quote:
    God Bless America.

    Now I have Obamanet to go with my Obamaphone, Obamacare, Obamastamps, and Obamafare.


    That is just horribly ignorant of you to say.


    What's ignorant about God Blessing America? Do you hate God or hate America?

  • 2 Hide
    OrumusST , August 4, 2014 9:51 PM
    I find this video sums up Cable companies in the US nicely....

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TaH9DHLqaeg&list=LLoxP4HVzEI6SHR1atAAtxiQ&index=22
  • 1 Hide
    airborne11b , August 4, 2014 10:15 PM
    Quote:
    Quote:
    Quote:
    God Bless America.

    Now I have Obamanet to go with my Obamaphone, Obamacare, Obamastamps, and Obamafare.


    That is just horribly ignorant of you to say.


    What's ignorant about God Blessing America? Do you hate God or hate America?



    It's hard to "hate" an imaginary character like this "God" thing. So hate in what way? Like hating Joffrey from GoT? Sure I guess.

    As for the Obama thing. If you think Obama is the problem, you haven't been paying attention for very long.
  • 1 Hide
    joaompp , August 4, 2014 10:17 PM
    Quote:
    This is just proof enough that Comcast is defiantly on bath salts.


    couldn't stop laughing after reading this, thank you knowom
  • 3 Hide
    Aslan7 , August 4, 2014 10:21 PM
    This is in reply to the original blog post at http://corporate.comcast.com/comcast-voices/comcast-to-offer-six-months-of-free-internet-essentials-service-and-announces-debt-forgiveness-plan

    For more than 8 hours Comcast has blocked every comment, including of course this one about my experiences with Comcast.

    I take issue with several point here VP Cohen.
    Comcast began offering internet essentials as a condition of the merger with NBC, not out of the goodness of it's heart. Comcast continues to offer the program in an attempt to pacify the FCC and attempt to gain support for your merger with Time Warner.

    Comcast Business class has been the worst service I ever received in terms of reliability. In the 6 months I had service I experienced more than 9 outages. Comcast forced me into a commercial contract I didn't want because they were the only option in the building. Comcast installers didn't bring the tools needed to install the drop properly and it took quite a number of phone calls and a third installer who also brought the wrong tools to finally get service installed properly.
    After 6 months of horridly unreliable service I moved my office to try and be rid of Comcast. I was informed you had me trapped in a year long contract and wanted $1200 for services that you weren't going to be providing me, and that were to terrible to use. You refused to cancel my service even upon my insistence. Because you had me under your thumb, I attempted to have you install service at my new Comcast serviced address. I verified that this address was serviced by Comcast. You, Comcast refused to install service saying you didn't service my address, this despite the fact that I verified that you did. On top of that you still wanted $1200 for service you were refusing to install.

    Comcast is a horrible company with the worst reliability of service of any company I've ever used. Comcast will refuse you service yet demand you pay for service they won't provide.
  • -2 Hide
    damric , August 4, 2014 10:45 PM
    Quote:
    Quote:
    Quote:
    Quote:
    God Bless America.

    Now I have Obamanet to go with my Obamaphone, Obamacare, Obamastamps, and Obamafare.


    That is just horribly ignorant of you to say.


    What's ignorant about God Blessing America? Do you hate God or hate America?



    It's hard to "hate" an imaginary character like this "God" thing. So hate in what way? Like hating Joffrey from GoT? Sure I guess.

    As for the Obama thing. If you think Obama is the problem, you haven't been paying attention for very long.


    I think you are confused. I'm happy I'm getting $10 internet and I voted for Obama twice for president and once for senator. Why is it a problem? I'm also an Atheist, but I don't hate Baby Jesus. Do you hate babies?
  • 0 Hide
    amk-aka-Phantom , August 5, 2014 2:09 AM
    Quote:
    Quote:
    Quote:
    Quote:
    Quote:
    God Bless America.

    Now I have Obamanet to go with my Obamaphone, Obamacare, Obamastamps, and Obamafare.


    That is just horribly ignorant of you to say.


    What's ignorant about God Blessing America? Do you hate God or hate America?



    It's hard to "hate" an imaginary character like this "God" thing. So hate in what way? Like hating Joffrey from GoT? Sure I guess.

    As for the Obama thing. If you think Obama is the problem, you haven't been paying attention for very long.


    I think you are confused. I'm happy I'm getting $10 internet and I voted for Obama twice for president and once for senator. Why is it a problem? I'm also an Atheist, but I don't hate Baby Jesus. Do you hate babies?


    Troll much? What if someone does? Not a big deal, you know.
  • 0 Hide
    hoofhearted , August 5, 2014 5:42 AM
    Comcast is taking lessons from the US government - control through socialism.
Display more comments