Three-Way 22" LED LCD Roundup: Dell, LG, And Samsung

Black And White Uniformity, Viewing Angles

Another measurable aspect of panel performance is brightness uniformity. Most manufacturers calibrate displays based on the center point of the screen. However, every area of the screen behaves differently. Sometimes you can get better performance in one specific region. As a result, we have added a nine-point black and white luminance test to measure the performance of each monitor's panel.

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Dell SR2320L
White Luminance cd/m^2
149.6964170.7121166.6663
149.5183182.223162.0439
166.221172.1839176.2046
Black Luminance cd/m^2
0.52290.57110.6191
0.56530.62650.6656
0.74900.78620.7148

The SR2220L appears to have slightly poor white and black luminance on the left side. This is apparent if you view the monitor from the left side instead of the right.

Swipe to scroll horizontally
LG E2241V
White Luminance cd/m^2
177.9729170.6266184.4701
177.4437204.3768178.1245
176.9572186.0513177.3021
Black Luminance cd/m^2
0.95770.77501.3384
1.00061.01471.3598
0.90210.82371.0901

The E2241V has poor white uniformity. We calibrate the center of the screen to 200 cd/m2, but every other region seems to fall behind. Black luminance is slightly more uniform, but the right side of the screen definitely has a problem yielding deep blacks. Remember that overall black luminance is poor on the E2241V. At 1 cd/m2, we can't seem to achieve deep blacks anywhere on the screen, even though we set the OSD's Black Level setting to low.

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Samsung S22A350H
White Luminance cd/m^2
176.8355182.9128173.9158
182.7114194.9993179.5684
177.4654180.0863170.4172
Black Luminance cd/m^2
0.79910.39270.7043
0.90280.44440.8126
0.73240.37910.5409

Similar to the E2241V, Samsung's S22A250H has a problem with white luminance. We are able to calibrate the center of the screen to 200 cd/m2, but this offsets other regions. Black uniformity behaves completely different. The center of the screen produces the deepest blacks, while the left and right suffer. This reduces the perception of contrast ratios if you're viewing from the left or right side, because you get lower white luminance and high black luminance.