Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in

Conclusion

Three 2.5" SAS Drives: Enterprise Data Giants, Compared
By , Achim Roos

A combination of the highest data transfer rates, the best I/O performance, and the lowest power consumption helps Hitachi's Ultrastar C10K600 edge out its competitors for top honors. Because of its performance, the drive can easily keep up with products that operate at 15 000 RPM. It is the fastest 10 000 RPM drive we have tested to date.

Seagate's Savvio 10K.5 is either just behind or on par with the Hitachi Ultrastar C10K600 in nearly all our test disciplines. It is really only in terms of I/O performance that the victor sets itself apart, clearly defeating the two Seagate devices (especially the Constellation.2).

If we ignore I/O performance, the Hitachi Ultrastar C10K600 and Seagate Savvio 10K.5 have even more in common than their high performance. With each drive featuring a MTBF of 2 million hours, they both clearly prioritize reliability.

On the other hand, Hitachi's Ultrastar C10K600 clearly loses the capacity contest because its maximum capacity of 600 GB is far below the Savvio 10K.5's 900 GB. Administrators satisfied with adequate (but not outstanding) I/O performance and roomier capacities should choose the Seagate Savvio 10K.5.

While it's by no means a bad drive, Seagate's Constellaion.2 suffers in a comparison to its competitors. It is a solid enterprise drive, but it cannot match the data throughput, access time, I/O performance, or low power consumption of either its in-house rival or the Hitachi drive. With a MTBF of 1.4 million hours, the Constellation.2 also doesn't have the reliability chops of the other drives. Its single trump card is a maximum 1000 GB capacity, which is unsurpassed to date.

React To This Article