ATI Graphics Card Buyer's Guide 2006, Part II

For this latest graphics card buyer's guide, we reviewed 27 cards using either ATI Radeon or Nvidia GeForce chips. Of those, two are designed for the AGP interface, while the rest use the PCI Express (PCIe) bus. The guide is split into three installments covering nine cards each. To be eligible for inclusion, the candidates must reach our lab in their retail packages. This means that we expect the final hardware version of the card in its final shipping box, with the software bundle and all necessary cables. The highlights of this second article is a Radeon X1600 Pro Golden Edition running at raised clock speeds..

Software bundles vary greatly between the card makers; in particular, the version numbers of the applications can be as much as three generations apart. Also, some companies expect the user to enter unreasonably long product keys that are up to 48 characters long, and it doesn't help that these keys are printed in minuscule fonts on the installation CD. Honestly, we think that if someone was willing to invest any kind of criminal energy into pirating software, it is rather unlikely that this person would target custom-tailored OEM versions of applications. The complete counterpoint to this paranoia is manifested in the full retail version of Power Director 3 that ships with Sapphire's Radeon X1800 XT and XL cards. Inexplicably, this software requires no product key at all!

We were also struck by the dominance of Cyberlink's products in the software bundles. Be it the software DVD player, video editing suite or image editor, most of these programs are made by the same company. These application bundles ship on what is called the "DVD Solution". Cyberlink uses the DVD Solution startup screens as advertising space for the company's other products. This is all understandable, to a point. It gets annoying, however, when after having already been forced to look at these ads and entering the product key, the user is confronted with an additional registration screen. We would say that here, less would be more.

On the whole, all companies try to bundle at least a software DVD player and some games with their cards. Vivo cards also ship with extensive software bundles that enable the buyer to make good use of the card's video inputs and outputs. The resulting movies can be copied to DV or burned to DVD or CD with the help of the programs' burning modules or standalone authoring and burning tools.

In the case of expensive cards such as the Radeon X1900 XTX, we recommend taking a closer look at our feature table at the end of the article. It offers a direct, side-by-side comparison of all cards of the same class, including information about their software bundle. Since most cards barely deviate from the chipmaker's reference design, the software bundle can tip the scales in favor of a certain card when trying to decide on a model.

The field of 27 review samples is divided into three articles of nine cards each; this article represents the second installment of nine cards. Benchmark results and feature table from the first part are included in this article as well. When the third part of this guide goes live, you will be able to compare all 27 cards with one another. Here is the list of cards that we cover in part 1 and part 3 of the buyer's guide.

Join our discussion on this topic

  1. Introduction
  2. Candidates From Part 1
  3. HIS Radeon X1800 XL
  4. HIS Radeon X1800 XL - Tools And Software
  5. Tools And Software, Continued
  6. Tools And Software, Continued
  7. HIS Radeon X1800 XL - Web Support
  8. HIS Radeon X1800 XL - Overclocking And Heat
  9. HIS Radeon X1900 XTX
  10. HIS Radeon X1900 XTX - Tools And Software
  11. Tools And Software, Continued
  12. Tools And Software, Continued
  13. HIS Radeon X1900 XTX - Web Support
  14. HIS Radeon X1900 XTX - Overclocking And Heat
  15. Powercolor Radeon X1600 XT
  16. Powercolor Radeon X1600 XT - Tools And Software
  17. Tools And Software, Continued
  18. Tools And Software, Continued
  19. Tools And Software, Continued
  20. Tools And Software, Continued
  21. Tools And Software, Continued
  22. Powercolor Radeon X1600 XT - Web Support
  23. Sapphire Radeon X1300 Pro
  24. Sapphire Radeon X1300 Pro - Tools And Software
  25. Sapphire Radeon X1300 Pro - Web Support
  26. Sapphire Radeon X1800 XT OC
  27. Sapphire Radeon X1800 XT OC - Tools And Software
  28. Tools And Software, Continued
  29. Tools And Software, Continued
  30. Sapphire Radeon X1800 XT OC - Web Support
  31. Sapphire Radeon X1800 XT OC - Overclocking And Heat
  32. Sapphire Radeon X1900 XTX
  33. Sapphire Radeon X1900 XTX - Tools And Software
  34. Tools And Software, Continued
  35. Sapphire Radeon X1900 XTX - Web Support
  36. Sapphire Radeon X1900 XTX - Overclocking And Heat
  37. Test Setup
  38. Benchmark Results
  39. Age Of Empire 3, Continued
  40. Black & White 2
  41. Black & White 2, Continued
  42. Call Of Duty 2
  43. Call Of Duty 2, Continued
  44. F.E.A.R
  45. F.E.A.R., Continued
  46. Quake 4
  47. Quake 4, Continued
  48. Serious Sam 2
  49. Serious Sam 2, Continued
  50. 3DMark06
  51. 3DMark06, Continued
  52. 3DMark06, Continued
  53. 3DMark06, Continued
  54. Power Consumption
  55. Conclusions
Create a new thread in the US Reviews comments forum about this subject
This thread is closed for comments
No comments yet
    Your comment