Conclusion

Previous Next
6:00 PM - 12/23/2008 by Thomas Soderstrom

Who makes the best-value motherboard for under $100? It really depends on what features you’re looking for. The Asus P5QL Pro offered the best performance and lowest price, but its performance leadership was too small to make us forget about the motherboard’s cramped layout. In fact, the MSI P43 Neo3-F tied for lowest price, and its relatively good layout makes it a similarly good choice in spite of its 0.52% slower performance.

Anyone trying to put off buying a graphics card will, of course, prefer a motherboard that has onboard graphics, and the good news for these buyers is that the ECS G45T-M2 is relatively fast and stable. The only reason we couldn’t recommend it to a wider group of value-seekers is that it can’t be overclocked at all, and overclocking is where most of us get better value.

Our top two picks for overclockers are the ASRock P45XE and Jetway BI-500. The BI-500 allowed slightly better CPU stability, but the P45XE allowed much greater bus speeds to be used. Because the average low-budget overclocker will be limited to low-multiplier processors, the P45XE might be the better choice.

Finally there’s the gaming crowd who could find extra value by using a pair of low-cost Radeon HD 4830 graphics cards in CrossFire mode. The two motherboards in today’s comparison that had the best overclocking capability also featured the CrossFire-supporting P45 chipset, but only one of these is a true CrossFire-enhanced design—the ASRock P45XE supports automatic switching between a single graphics card in PCIe 2.0 x16 mode and dual cards in x8 mode, while the Jetway BI-500 forces the second graphics card to limp along using previous-generation PCIe technology {and} x4 pathways.

Good performance and excellent overclocking capability make ASRock’s motherboard look like a good performance value, but added features are where the P45XE really shines. These include proper CrossFire support, automatic PCIe switching for CrossFire mode, and the rarely-seen but much-appreciated ability to set AHCI drives as removable devices. This overwhelming combination of performance, overclocking capabilities, and mid-priced features leads us to select ASRock’s P45XE as the best overall value in a budget-enthusiast motherboard.

Talkback
V3NOM 12/24/2008 12:10 PM
Show
cangelini 12/24/2008 12:42 PM
Hide
-5+

FWIW, the issue with text disappearing from the commenting box as you're typing is something I've reported and m waiting for a fix still. Thanks for confirming that it's still an issue.

rjcorrin 12/24/2008 2:16 PM
Show
jsc 12/24/2008 2:38 PM
Hide
-5+

"What is a >$100 board going to give me?

I have a DS3P becuae i need the exrta SATA ports.

Anonymous 12/24/2008 3:11 PM
Hide
-13+

I run the I.T. department for a couple small businesses, and the sub $100 motherboard is almost essential in today's economy. Sure I could use a $120-$150 motherboard, DDR3, 10000 RPM hard drive, and all kinds of other things, but I would end up with a system that is only marginal faster in business applications for 3+ times the price. Take one of the G3x or G4x motherboards, 2GB DDR2, Intel E7x00 CPU and 80GB+ HDD and you have a system that will meet the needs of a good majority of businesses and home users. I am personally a gamer and can see the value in the higher end components; but there are a lot of other market segments out there where this makes financial sense.

rjcorrin 12/24/2008 3:17 PM
Show
rjcorrin 12/24/2008 4:02 PM
Show
gaiden2k7 12/24/2008 4:06 PM
Hide
-4+

I got a Gigabyte UD3P for $99 during black friday... would that top this list? :)

Noya 12/24/2008 4:27 PM
Show
malveaux 12/24/2008 4:28 PM
Show
gwolfman 12/24/2008 4:46 PM
Hide
-6+

lol @ rjcorrin's 1st comment.

In reply: Maybe he already had HDDs laying around of smaller size and thought it best to save money by spending a few more dollars on more SATA ports than hundreds on new 3 x 1TB HDDs. You're reasoning is asinine and self contradicting.

Tindytim 12/24/2008 4:47 PM
Hide
-2+

rjcorrin :
Did you happen to notice that the comment box detects your errors and underlines them in red?


Did you happen to notice you're using Firefox? It, not this comment box, does that.

rjcorrin :
"I have a DS3P becuae i need the exrta SATA ports."The DS3L has 4 Sata ports which could easily handle 3 terabytes and a DVD drive. You could have saved money by editing down your porn collection and deleting your stolen .iso's of the entire "Friday the 13th" collection.


And what about Raid? And all the PC's I've had in this Millennium have had 2 Removable Disk drives.

Not to mention I have multiple OSes installed, and an extra drive I use for storage (I reformat often). So I have plenty of drives.

gwolfman 12/24/2008 5:11 PM
Hide
-1+

Ummm, maybe I missed it but I didn't see anywhere that said what video/graphics card was used in these test. Anyone!?! I'm curious because of the power consumption numbers. Thanks.

cambion 12/24/2008 5:14 PM
Hide
-3+

Attention to detail alert... The MSI Neo3-f has eight SATA ports not, as the article claims, six.

rjcorrin 12/24/2008 5:18 PM
Show
rjcorrin 12/24/2008 5:20 PM
Hide
--1+

cambion :
Attention to detail alert... The MSI Neo3-f has eight SATA ports not, as the article claims, six.



This is the exact number of ports on the DS3P. So, again, what does a >$100 board going to give me?

tmc 12/24/2008 5:24 PM
Hide
--3+

Though this does give you an what our Taiwan & Chinese friends have in the goodie bin at the local computer store.. you will still want to wait to bu

tmc 12/24/2008 5:26 PM
Hide
-1+

tmc :
Though this does give you an what our Taiwan & Chinese friends have in the goodie bin at the local computer store.. you will still want to wait to bu


Ugh, got cut off..
Wait to build your system until Q1, Q2 processor price cuts of 2009.. especially if you have your heart set on $ inTEL $ 775 vs amd.

rjcorrin 12/24/2008 5:29 PM
Show
orangedrink 12/24/2008 5:29 PM
Hide
-6+

Merry Christmas


Comments are closed on this page.

Sponsored links

All about Motherboards
 Latest Motherboards articles
All Motherboards articles

Newsletters


  • Ask your question about IT issues
  • Post

Partners

The Games selection

violent : More Mindless Violence Basic shooting game, but still so powerful! Use the mouse to take aim and shoot at the little beasties before they get to you. Use Space to reload....
action : Yoyo the Star Yoyo is a young girl who recently graduated and dreams to become a movie star (don't we all). You'll have to guide her on the path to stardom,...
Ads

Sponsored links