Nothing can be said in this conclusion that is more valuable than the actual data itself. If, for some reason, you skipped the individual charts, jumping right to the conclusion, you’ll likely not grasp what this story is all about: balance.
For each chart, we recommended a minimum level of CPU and GPU needed to play the game at that particular resolution. By tallying results of all 27 tests (seven games times all resolutions), we’ll summarize how often each solution was able to reach our targeted level of performance.
Again, a word of warning here: while valuable in many ways, this chart has the potential to be misused. Our minimum recommendations are just that, minimums, and only a guideline for obtaining maximum image quality and playable performance as affordably as possible.
Not a single one of today’s data charts contain a “Too Little CPU” quadrant, as all five overclocked Intel processors provided playable performance levels in each game. The four AMD Radeon cards reached the same number of targets, regardless of the processor, while pairing with the overclocked Pentium E6300 at times held the three GeForce cards back from the mark. Otherwise, these flat lines confirm the graphics card will determine what resolution is playable for each game.
The Radeon HD 5970 and overclocked GeForce GTX 295 dual-GPU cards managed to deliver playable performance in every test except Crysis at 2560x1600. Hot on their heels was the overclocked Radeon HD 5870, which struggled at 2560x1600 in S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Clear Sky and was awarded only half a point for borderline 1920x1200 performance in Crysis. Other borderline cases falling just below our target were the Radeon HD 5750 at 1920x1200 in Far Cry 2, and the GeForce GTX 260 at 2560x1600 in Need For Speed Shift.
Often, our cheapest acceptable solution was still far out of balance and would benefit from adding more CPU horsepower to the mix. In fact, the above chart depicts so little benefit from the processor that we’ll add one at the other end of the scale, providing a quick glimpse at how much CPU is needed to get the most out of each graphics card. Here we add up the all the framerates from all 27 tests and plot this global total. High FPS at low resolutions can skew these results, so the same warning applies here. Be careful not to misuse this chart and check the individual games and resolutions that matter to you for determining the balance you’ll need.
There are no real surprises in how our staggered grouping of graphics cards rank once paired with an overclocked quad-core processor. However we have seen how quickly these rankings change when platform bottlenecks are introduced. Overclocking reduced the impact by a large margin, but by no means did it eliminate it altogether. In general, Nvidia’s GeForce solutions are less forgiving than AMD’s offerings in terms of processor requirements, having seemingly greater thread dependency. While the Radeon HD 5970 offered higher performance than the GeForce GTX 295, the two often shared nearly identical-shaped scaling curves. And the same can be said for the Radeon HD 5870 and GeForce GTX 285 single-GPU cards. Finally, the Radeon HD 4890 once again shines as an attractive solution for those running older/slower processors.
Gone are the days when a high-clocked Core 2 Duo ruled the world of gaming processors. But overall, the E8400 still held its own, even in games thought to be well-threaded. Having one-third the L2 cache and over 500 MHz less core clock rate, the Pentium E6300 delivered acceptable performance for such a budget processor, but we can’t help feel a little disappointed how often it limited the higher-end cards.
We are eager to see how well AMD’s value-oriented processors fair in comparison. Certainly there is still good evidence in support of a quad-core processor for gaming, and the overclocked Core i5 and i7 proved overall to offer the highest level of performance and the most breathing room for the dual-GPU graphics cards.
We hope you enjoyed this first look into overclocking. Next up, in Part 4, we’ll crank up the core speeds of our AMD processors and see how well they stack up to the Intel chips presented today.
- Balanced Platform Series Introduction
- Graphics Cards
- Memory, Hard Drive, Power Supply, Coolers
- Pricing, Methodology, And A Sample Chart
- Overclocking, Test System Configuration, And Benchmarks
- Benchmark Results: Crysis
- Benchmark Results: Far Cry 2
- Benchmark Results: S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Clear Sky
- Benchmark Results: Grand Theft Auto IV
- Benchmark Results: Fallout 3
- Benchmark Results: Need For Speed Shift
- Benchmark Results: World In Conflict
- Power Consumption