Nvidia unexpectedly replaces a damaged RTX 5090 GPU despite user blunder — $1,999 flagship GPU escapes paperweight status against all odds

GeForce RTX 5090 Founders Edition
(Image credit: Nvidia)

An extremely fortunate RTX 5090 owner who contacted Nvidia after breaking their GPU while trying to install a custom liquid cooling block has received a brand new card free of charge, despite voiding their warranty as a result of the daring modification.

The GeForce RTX 5090 Founders Edition is arguably among the best graphics cards available currently. However, the Blackwell flagship features a notably delicate design, which could pose risks if you damage one of the fragile internal components. It is somewhat refreshing to see a damaged GeForce RTX 5090 that is not caused by the melting of the 16-pin power connector from time to time. Although this individual was fortunate enough to have his graphics card with a broken connector replaced by Nvidia, this may be an exceptional case; nonetheless, it sets a notable precedent.

Nvidia Positive Response to 5090 FE Fragile Connector Issue. - YouTube Nvidia Positive Response to 5090 FE Fragile Connector Issue. - YouTube
Watch On

The courageous user disassembled his GeForce RTX 5090 Founders Edition in order to install a custom water block aimed at liquid cooling the graphics card. The individual asserts that he handled the disconnection and reconnection of the PCIe board with care, refraining from exerting unnecessary force on the 128-pin connector. Nevertheless, NorthridgeFix subsequently identified that the user had bent one pin and damaged another, which was sufficient to render the GeForce RTX 5090 Founders Edition non-functional. The challenge associated with a modular design is that all exerted pressure from the PCIe board is transmitted to the 128-pin connector.

Having exhausted all options, the distressed owner contacted Nvidia to inquire whether the chip manufacturer would supply or sell a replacement board for the damaged graphics card. Although Nvidia confirmed that it did not sell replacement parts, the company agreed to replace the graphics card at no cost after the issue was escalated to a senior representative. Clearly, the owner was exceptionally fortunate, as the GeForce RTX 5090 Founders Edition's warranty was voided immediately upon disassembly. The position for liquid-cooling a graphics card varies depending on the partner. Certain brands permit it, provided that the graphics card remains undamaged during the procedure, whereas others explicitly prohibit it under the warranty terms.

If liquid cooling is included in your plans, it would be advisable to consider purchasing a custom GeForce RTX 5090, as aftermarket designs are generally more convenient. Nevertheless, there remains some risk, as with everything in life. Alternatively, you may opt for one of the GeForce RTX 5090 variants equipped with an AIO liquid cooler or a pre-installed water block, if you're willing to pay a premium. However, if you are among the fortunate owners of a GeForce RTX 5090 Founders Edition, it is highly recommended that you refrain from disassembling it. We suspect Nvidia may handle these situations on a case-by-case basis, so you may not have the same luck as the owner in this story.

Google Preferred Source

Follow Tom's Hardware on Google News, or add us as a preferred source, to get our latest news, analysis, & reviews in your feeds.

Zhiye Liu
News Editor, RAM Reviewer & SSD Technician

Zhiye Liu is a news editor, memory reviewer, and SSD tester at Tom’s Hardware. Although he loves everything that’s hardware, he has a soft spot for CPUs, GPUs, and RAM.

  • A Stoner
    Sounds like a win.
    Reply
  • Konomi
    Rare, but appreciated. Hopefully not the last time we see something like this (although I hope it is the last time we hear of someone damaging their card).
    Reply
  • anghellic
    Technically though because you broke it on teardown its not because of wear and tear its harder to get them to honor it so yeab you are lucky
    Reply
  • anghellic
    anghellic said:
    Technically though because you broke it on teardown its not because of wear and tear its harder to get them to honor it so yeab you are lucky
    If it just happend because of a issue with manufacturer or something happend during use of it they are certain legal actions that can be taken
    Reply
  • anghellic
    anghellic said:
    If it just happend because of a issue with manufacturer or something happend during use of it they are certain legal actions that can be taken
    But simple lesson in this is if you are not a proffesional and even if you are do not take fe edition apart they deisgned that card to be as complicated as possible so people wouldnt
    Reply
  • derekullo
    What are the chances of installing a custom liquid cooling block going wrong twice in a row !!
    Reply
  • Dementoss
    anghellic said:
    Technically though because you broke it on teardown its not because of wear and tear its harder to get them to honor it so yeab you are lucky
    There's nothing to honour, no warranty covers damage directly caused by the owner. But, some companies will be more generous, if the customer is honest and polite.
    Reply
  • buttabean2
    Are they referring to the pcie connector? It's actually a bolt on piece that attaches to the board. I actually put a wb on my 5090 fe and you can take it off. I do not recommend doing the wb due to the liquid metal. It's not fun and it can be a disaster very easily
    Reply
  • Winterson
    Not mentioned but the 5090 and 5080 are overheating which results in a black screen.

    NVIDIA has released driver version 572.60, whichaddresses various black screen issues listed in the fixed bug list – Various black screen issues
    NVIDIA has released GeForce Hotfix Driver Version 572.65to fix the Black Screen during boot when the monitor is connectedthrough DisplayPort.
    Reply