$1,299 Asus OLED gaming monitors are arriving with cracked panels for many buyers — cut-down packaging with no protection for the panel gets the blame

The ROG Swift OLED PG32UCDM Gen3 (PG32UCDM3) is one of the best gaming monitors and one of the priciest on the market. However, not even its top-tier specifications can save the premium OLED monitor from what appears to be a serious flaw: its packaging. Multiple frustrated users have taken to the OLED_Gaming subreddit to share photographs and stories about how their $1,299 monitors arrived with cracked screens, with the flimsy packaging blamed as the culprit.

Reddit user Rude-Employee7251 posted high-resolution photographs that leave no doubt about the extent of the damage. The lower right corner of their brand-new monitor was visibly cracked. In a frustrated account, the buyer described the packaging as “weirdly unprotected compared to other Asus releases.” Rude-Employee7251 is now navigating the tedious RMA process to obtain a replacement, a situation that should never have occurred with a premium product.

The Reddit post quickly gained traction, and other victims have chimed in to share similar experiences and echo concerns about the company’s declining packaging standards. Redditors siouxsian, advice_throwaway323, and Gillersan reported identical damage in the same spot as Rude-Employee7251. Although it's not a contest, Jonesy7mm's and WriterConfident3186's cases were the most catastrophic, with substantial fractures in the OLED panels.

Image 1 of 6

One Redditor, winterbegins, conducted an in-depth analysis of Asus's packaging for the PG32UCDM3. There were several shortcomings. Drawing on their past monitor purchases and measurements, winterbegins reported that the cardboard box protecting the $1,299 monitor was significantly thinner than those of other monitors they owned. The PG32UCDM3’s box measured just 4.7mm thick, a full 1.5mm thinner than the packaging for the KTC M27P6 and LG G5, both of which came in at 6.2mm. It may sound like a minor difference, but every millimeter of protection counts. The PG32UCDM3 is a full 32-inch monitor, yet, as winterbegins observed, the box was “not much bigger than” the M27P6’s packaging, even though that model is five inches smaller.

However, the devil is in the details, and that’s exactly where things begin to unravel for the PG32UCDM3. The outer box may be just one contributor to the fragility of the packaging, but the choice of interior protection could be the more important factor. The PG32UCDM3 uses eggshell cardboard, a molded pulp material you might recognize from egg cartons. While eggshell cardboard is environmentally friendly and reasonably strong, it simply doesn’t compete with styrofoam when it comes to shock absorption. Imagine a delivery driver bumping or tossing your $1,299 gaming monitor onto your front porch. Styrofoam may cushion that blow, but eggshell cardboard is more likely to transmit the force to the delicate OLED panel.

Even more alarmingly, the eggshell cardboard wrapper’s design includes a big cutout in the lower half. The PG32UCDM3 sits face-first on the cardboard during shipping. There's no padding underneath. It could explain why some units are arriving with damage concentrated in the lower right section of the panel. There's nothing more than an eggshell cardboard and the outer box standing between the OLED panel and the perils of shipping.

While it's easy to point fingers at the retailer or the shipping company for damage during transit, Asus shares some responsibility. When you're paying $1,299 for a gaming monitor, the packaging should reflect the same level of quality. While these incidents may not yet be widespread, the growing number of similar complaints insinuates more than just a string of bad luck.

Follow Tom's Hardware on Google News, or add us as a preferred source, to get our latest news, analysis, & reviews in your feeds.