Low-Power Face-Off: AMD's Athlon X2 Vs. Intel's Core 2 Duo

Regular Power: AMD Athlon 64 X2 5400+ BE (65 W TDP)

While the low-power parts are named Athlon X2, the regular models are still sold as Athlon 64 X2. We wanted to also include a regular 65 W AMD processor to look at the power consumption difference, so we decided to get the one that makes the most sense: the 5400+ Black Edition at 2.8 GHz stock speed. There would be an Athlon 64 X2 5600+ at 2.9 GHz, which is also still rated at 65 W TDP—all faster models are 89 W parts—but the memory clock of this part would not be able to hit the full 400 MHz for DDR2-800 operation.

Remember that the CPUs have to derive the memory clock from the core clock: 2,800 MHz divided by 7 is a perfect match for 400 MHz memory clock speed, but 2,900 MHz divided by 7.5—which is required to stay within specifications—results in 387 MHz or DDR2-773, which would have erased the 100 MHz clock speed benefit. In addition to these issues, this processor is a so-called Black Edition, meaning that you can overclock it using an adjustable multiplier.

The voltage of this mainstream 65 W processor is slightly higher than the 1.20 V we found on the Athlon X2 5050e: we tracked 1.295 V at full clock speed, and 1.075 V when idle at 1.0 GHz core clock. This alone makes quite a difference, and the clock speed increase of 200 MHz does the rest. The system running the 5400+ required 4 W more idle power and 21 W more peak power. Both fail to impress, as the total system peak power of 106 W is very much the same as on the Intel comparison system, which in this case was running a Core 2 Quad Q9550s low power 65 W quad-core processor. Looking at the benchmark results, it becomes obvious that this CPU only makes sense if you overclock it.

TOPICS
Latest in CPUs
Tech Deals
AMD's non-X3D Ryzen 9 9950X processor hits an all-time low in Amazon's Big Spring Sale 2025
Ryzen 5 9600X
AMD Ryzen 5 9600X hits all-time low price
Core Ultra 200S CPU
An Arrow Lake refresh may still be in the cards with only K and KF models, claims leaker
Tech Deals
Our alternate pick for the best gaming CPU is $190 cheaper than the 9800X3D right now - pick up the AMD Ryzen 7 9700X for just $289
ASRock fixes AM5 motherboard by cleaning it
ASRock claims to fix 'burned out' AM5 motherboard by cleaning the socket
Ryzen AI
AMD's Gorgon Point APU line-up breaks cover — Allegedly aiming for a 2026 launch
Latest in Features
Free Alternatives to Photoshop
Five Best Photoshop Alternatives Tested: Image Editing for Free
Awekeys Antiques Metal keycaps
Awekeys Antiques Metal keycaps are Viking-themed luxury for your fingertips
The Gigabyte X870E AORUS ELITE WIFI7
Get the most out of your processor with this motherboard's Turbo Mode
AMD RDNA 4 and Radeon RX 9000-series GPUs
AMD RDNA 4 and Radeon RX 9000-series GPUs start at $549: Specifications, release date, pricing, and more revealed
MSI Prestige GPU
Tested: Intel's Arrow Lake 140T iGPU mostly maintains an edge over AMD's older 880m
MechBoards Hyper7 R4
I’m typing this on the world’s largest keyboard, a 178-key beast designed to make you more productive