Exploring SSD Performance In Battlefield 3, F1 2011, And Rift
Hard Drive Performance Comparison
There is no debating that SSDs help improve performance. However, we've received many requests asking us to provide clearer benchmarks highlighting the precise difference between solid-state and conventional storage in games.
Unfortunately, we include the time it takes to navigate menus and watch cut scenes when we record the trace for each game. As a result, the storage analysis benchmarks that covered the past several pages don't give us a good way to directly compare hard drives.
However, when we factor out menu navigation and skip over the cut scenes, the contrast between hard drives and SSDs becomes clearer. Any performance delta reflected in the charts above and below is the result of the storage workload. For example, there's a huge difference in Rift due to the random nature of the data access patterns. In comparison, F1 2011 sees a very small performance boost due to its low queue depth sequential workload.
Stay On the Cutting Edge: Get the Tom's Hardware Newsletter
Get Tom's Hardware's best news and in-depth reviews, straight to your inbox.
Current page: Hard Drive Performance Comparison
Prev Page Gamplay In Rift Next Page Frame Rates Examined-
clonazepam Makes sense. I'll install sw:tor to the ssd after i figure out how to make its 20GB fit on it lol... the rest go to the HDD...Reply
Good read. Thanks for being so thorough. -
IMO, a WD Caviar Black or a Samsung Spinpoint F3 would have been a better test drive than the Green one.Reply
-
christoforo Thanks to all the reviews you made here guys. A couple of months ago I started planning my ssd purchase, and i decided to buy a Kingston HyperX 240gb bundle kit. I cant wait till it arrives. I have advanced computer skills, so many things I thought from personal experiences are published here, like I knew some games are more write dependant or read dependant from and HDD, and about the apps on the background on WIN7, and many many more. I already ordered my SSD, but its nice to have a serious review about ssds on gaming performance. Its all about the speed that the apps can be done by write/read on a ssd on the background that really matters, from this simple thing is that anyone willing to upgrade to an ssd can benefit with a smoother playable experience.Reply -
gmcizzle Storage can actually make a difference in FPS in certain situations. Only put in 2gb or so of RAM in the test system and rerun Battlefield 3, and the difference in frame rates will be different between HDD and SSD as the game switches to secondary storage once RAM is exhausted.Reply -
Supernova1138 True, but it is much more cost effective to add more RAM to your system in that circumstance than to get an SSD large enough for your OS and a couple of games. With RAM so inexpensive these days there is absolutely no reason to be running low on it under any gaming scenario.Reply -
cumi2k4 Agreed with xyzqwerty, please do another test with faster drives such as wd black or the f3. Comparing the ssd with green version is like racing your turtle with the neighbor's hare.Reply -
acku cumi2k4Agreed with xyzqwerty, please do another test with faster drives such as wd black or the f3. Comparing the ssd with green version is like racing your turtle with the neighbor's hare.Reply
I'm a little confused why you would want to see that comparison. We established there was no diff between a slow HDD and a fast SSD. And you expect a difference between a fast HDD and fast SSD?
Cheers,
Andrew Ku
TomsHardware.com -
silverblue asnorton44Interesting to see it won't imrpove all gameplayI see what you did there. :PReply -
FunSurfer 9523292 said:I'm a little confused why you would want to see that comparison. We established there was no diff between a slow HDD and a fast SSD. And you expect a difference between a fast HDD and fast SSD?
Cheers,
Andrew Ku
TomsHardware.com
He probably want to see that comparison on the "Hard Drive Performance Comparison" page, where is a big difference between SSD and HDD performance (the HDD up to 477% slower)