Integrated VGA & How Good Is ATi's Radeon 9100 IGP?
Test Setup
We compared ATi's new IGP 9100 chipset with integrated graphics with the candidates from our last comparison . Although some of the drivers used in that review have since become outdated, this should have little if any influence on the chips' performance, considering the performance level we're talking about here. Tests showed no improvement whatsoever with updated drivers. This can be explained by the simple fact that these chipsets have been in the market for such a long time that their performance potential has already been completely exploited by the drivers.
For reference, we compared the integrated solution with a $50 ATi 9200 graphics card which sports 64 MB of video memory and supports AGP 8x. Its 3D core is based on the same architecture as ATi's IGP9100 (RS300). To make clear what level of 3D performance is available today and what a role graphics performance plays in games we also included a Radeon 9800 Pro with 128 MB in this comparison.
System 1 - Intel 865G | |
---|---|
Motherboard | Gigabyte GA-8IG 1000 PRO |
Processor | Intel Pentium 4 3.06 GHzHyperthreading Enabled533 MHz MHz FSB |
RAM | 2x 256 MB DDR333 CL2Dual Channel |
System 2 - NVIDIA nForce 2 | |
Motherboard | Soltek SL-75MRN |
Processor | AMD Athlon XP 3000+ |
RAM | 2x 256 MB DDR333 CL2Dual Channel |
System 3 - SIS651 | |
Motherboard | Shuttle FS51 |
Processor | Intel Pentium 4 3.06 GHz533 MHz MHz FSB |
RAM | 2x 256 MB DDR333 CL2Single Channel |
System 4 - Radeon 9100IGP | |
Motherboard | Gigabyte GA-8TRS300M |
Processor | Intel Pentium 4 3.06 GHz533 MHz MHz FSB |
RAM | 2x 256 MB DDR333 CL2Dual Channel |
System 5 - Radeon 9100IGP | |
Motherboard | ATI Reference Board |
Processor | Intel Pentium 4 3.06 GHz533 MHz MHz FSB |
RAM | 2x 256 MB DDR333 CL2Dual Channel |
Drivers & Configuration | |
Graphics Driver | Detonator FX v45.23ATI Catalyst v3.6ATI Catalyst v4.1 |
Graphics Cards | Radeon 9200 SE 64 MBRadeon 9800 PRO 256 MB |
DirectX Version | 9.0b |
OS | Windows XP Professional SP1 |
Benchmarks | |
Unreal Tournament 2003 | Version 2225Antalus Flyby |
Quake III Team Arena | Patch V1.32Custom Timedemo |
Serious Sam Second Encounter | Retail Version v1.07(Demo: Valley of the Jaguar) |
3DMark 2001 SE | Version 3.3.0 |
Aquanox2 Revelation | Retail Version v2.159 |
Stay On the Cutting Edge: Get the Tom's Hardware Newsletter
Get Tom's Hardware's best news and in-depth reviews, straight to your inbox.