America's largest grid wants to cut power to new data centers first during shortages — 50MW-plus data centers must bring their own electricity generation to avoid shutoffs

AI data center next to houses
(Image credit: Getty / Brendam Smialowski)

PJM Interconnection, the grid operator serving 67 million people across 13 states and Washington, D.C., asked federal regulators on Thursday to approve rules that would cut power to new data centers ahead of households during supply shortages, Reuters reports. The filing with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission follows two consecutive capacity auctions that failed to secure enough generation, and PJM's board projects roughly 70 GW of new large load by 2038 against roughly 15 GW of generation retired since 2022.

Existing facilities aren't affected, with the proposed Interim Resource Adequacy Service applying only to new loads of 50 MW or more at a single site that connect without bringing their own generation, or otherwise securing supply, by June 1, 2027. Those facilities would be curtailed before PJM deploys Pre-Emergency Load Management, which are the demand-response programs that pay other customers to cut consumption during grid stress.

Attached to the scheme is a new Large Load Registry, which tracks the location and megawatt draw of every 50 MW-plus site in PJM's territory and whether it brings its own supply. Affected customers would be compensated at a FERC-approved hourly rate set at 50% of the penalty rate PJM pays existing demand-response resources during full grid emergencies. It’s understood that operators can waive that payment in line with the White House's Ratepayer Protection Pledge.

Latest Videos FromTom's Hardware

PJM can't actually flip the switch itself, however. The operator told Reuters that it lacks the authority to curtail individual sites and would need to rely on utilities and state governments to carry out the reductions, which is why the registry data will be shared with states to set load-shedding priorities. Virginia, home to the world's largest data center cluster, has already ordered operators to pay for their own dedicated grid infrastructure.

Data centers in PJM’s territory have been curtailed before under a Department of Energy emergency order issued in May, which enabled the operator to call on large loads with backup generation as a last resort ahead of rolling blackouts. PJM expected less than 5,800 MW of reserves during that heat event, with Maryland and Virginia under the most strain. Thursday's filing would turn that one-off emergency authority into an established mechanism.

In July, PJM’s capacity auction for the 2028/29 delivery year hit its $325 per megawatt-day price cap and still came up some 6,800 MW short of the operator’s reliability requirement. Its independent market monitor has attributed a 75.5% jump in regional power costs directly to data center demand.

A separate one-time backstop procurement, running September 30 through October 21 with offers capped at $555 per megawatt-day, aims to backfill the shortfall, and from the 2029/2030 auction onward PJM plans to exclude new large loads that don't bring their own supply from the demand it procures for at all.

Google Preferred Source

Follow Tom's Hardware on Google News, or add us as a preferred source, to get our latest news, analysis, & reviews in your feeds.

Luke James
Contributor

Luke James is a freelance writer and journalist.  Although his background is in legal, he has a personal interest in all things tech, especially hardware and microelectronics, and anything regulatory. 

  • bigdragon
    I have an even better idea: Force the construction of a new nuclear power plant in Loudoun county Virginia. Yes, it would have to go adjacent to or on one of the islands of the Potomac River. I can already hear the gnashing of teeth from people screaming about the sanctity of the river, the need to keep it all natural and pristine, land values, and how important the river ecosystem is. These same people also demand that their neighbors carve up their communities with transmission lines and pay more for utilities while also bragging about how low the taxes are in Loudoun because of all the data center income.

    PJM is going to keep carving states up with transmission lines, increasing delivery/transmission fees, and failing to meet energy capacity requirements until we do something about the source of the problem. We cannot allow one jurisdiction to approve the construction of and further incentivize future construction for more data centers than the grid can handle today, tomorrow, and in the near future.

    Loudoun can build its own power plants to power its data centers. It doesn't need to be pulling electricity from Three Mile Island in Harrisburg, PA and continue screwing over everyone living within PJM's territory.
    Reply
  • Scott_Tx
    By the time they could build a nuclear power plant the AI bubble will have long burst and they know that. And its one of the most expensive forms of power too.
    Reply
  • rgd1101
    Scott_Tx said:
    By the time they could build a nuclear power plant the AI bubble will have long burst and they know that. And its one of the most expensive forms of power too.
    more reliable too
    Reply
  • bigdragon
    Scott_Tx said:
    By the time they could build a nuclear power plant the AI bubble will have long burst and they know that. And its one of the most expensive forms of power too.
    Loudoun would still use the power. Every big tech company has data centers there. Plenty of content delivery, virtual machine, cloud storage, and data analytics going on. They're so desperate for power that companies like Microsoft dumped tons of money into restarting Three Mile Island's remaining reactor, and PJM has been busy with transmission lines to move that power from PA to VA. Every new Loudoun data center is having to provide their own on-site generation because of how bad the PJM energy deficit is.

    I really don't see an alternative to a nuclear power plant on the Potomac.
    Reply
  • wwenze1
    Stock market will be very interesting when the robot-investors suddenly stop.
    Reply
  • EclipseGST94
    Scott_Tx said:
    By the time they could build a nuclear power plant the AI bubble will have long burst and they know that. And its one of the most expensive forms of power too.
    "Bubble" LOL. T Boomer- "those silly computers are a fad"
    Reply
  • Eximo
    Scott_Tx said:
    By the time they could build a nuclear power plant the AI bubble will have long burst and they know that. And its one of the most expensive forms of power too.
    Bubble burst doesn't mean the AI goes away. It just means a whole lot of companies fail, go bankrupt, sell their assets at a fire sale. Economy and stock market take a massive drop. The big players survive, buy up the assets, and sell the capabilities to a realistic market. Not the fanciful one where consumers have 1.5 trillion to spend on AI services over the next few years.

    Sure some datacenters might go dark for a while. But once the infrastructure is built, the owners will hold on to them until someone comes along and wants the capacity. Always be ever-increasing storage and traditional hosting demands if nothing else.

    Internet didn't go away when the dotcom bubble burst. You just saw a whole bunch of companies that were extremely overvalued have all their debt collectors come calling when they couldn't prove out revenue streams.
    Reply
  • circadia
    EclipseGST94 said:
    "Bubble" LOL. T Boomer- "those silly computers are a fad"
    instead of properly arguing, you decided to just throw a random insult in. lol, really.
    Reply
  • logainofhades
    EclipseGST94 said:
    "Bubble" LOL. T Boomer- "those silly computers are a fad"

    Must be a kid that didn't live through the dot com bubble.

    Scott_Tx said:
    By the time they could build a nuclear power plant the AI bubble will have long burst and they know that. And its one of the most expensive forms of power too.

    Far better than solar or wind, with regards to reliabilty and acerage needed. Newer technology has made recycling spent fuel rods possible, so far less waste needs to be stored somewhere, roughly 4% vs trying to store all of it.
    Reply