Page 1:Power Protection Or Rage Prevention?
Page 2:Why So Pricey?
Page 3:APC Smart-UPS SMT1500
Page 4:SMT1500 Management Software
Page 5:CyberPower CP1500PFCLCD
Page 6:CP1500PFCLCD Management Software
Page 7:Opti-UPS Durable Series DS1500B
Page 8:DS1500B Management Software
Page 9:Tripp Lite SmartPro SMART1500SLT
Page 10:SMART1500SLT Management Software
Page 11:Test Settings
Page 12:Benchmark Results
Why So Pricey?
Most of our enthusiast-class builds have an approximate value of $2000. Because a $200 UPS represents only 10% of the system’s price, we thought a roundup of those would bolster our “cheap protection” argument. That’s when the realities of modern hardware slapped us in the face.
Problem 1: Real vs. Apparent Power
Have you ever wondered why a UPS of enormous VA rating might be required to support a far more moderate wattage load? Aren’t watts calculated by multiplying volts by amps, the V and A in VA ratings? Getting to the bottom of this required us to think about a few of the things we learned in high-school science classes and apply those lessons to a Web search.
The AC (alternating current) power that comes from our wall jacks is graphically represented as a sine wave, where the center line is equal to ground. Voltage is rated using RMS values, so a 120 V line is 170 V peak (RMS * √2). In a perfect world, current (amperage) would track force (voltage) perfectly, resulting in a peak wattage (at the crest of the wave) that’s far higher than the average wattage for a single cycle. That is to say, even in a perfect world, the circuit must be designed to handle more than its rated power.
Unfortunately, amperage load doesn’t always track voltage perfectly, and this is where VA and watts part ways. When voltage and amperage are slightly out of phase, a portion of the energy from the load (such as a computer’s power supply) returns to the source (such as a UPS battery). Though the cancelled-out power reduces the energy required from the source, all the parts between the source and the load must be beefed-up to carry it.
VA ratings are a way for power supply companies to advertise the current-carrying capacity of those middle parts without discussing the continuous load the battery is able to supply to the PC.
Problem 2: Active PFC and Step Waves
While traditional PC power supplies focus on reducing electrical noise on the output rails, Power Factor Correction-equipped power supplies also attempt to reduce the noise the unit places on its power source. Filters align amperage and voltage cycles, reducing the portion of energy that is returned from the load to the source. That is to say, a power supply with perfect PFC (1.0) would never require the middle parts to carry more VA than the PC consumes in watts. With enthusiast PC power supplies now advertising 0.95-0.99 PFC, it’s time most of us learned to ignore VA ratings and focus on the wattage capacity of our UPS devices.
Yet active PFC power supplies can also be more sensitive to wave form than traditional PC power supplies have been. Dan Farnsworth of APC explains:
“For some basic info, Europe has required that all electronics devices now be made with PFC power supplies for a while now. And they are becoming more common here in the US as time passes. These power supplies are more efficient...but also more expensive. Accordingly, in order to minimize cost increases associated with active PFC power supplies, some manufacturers are cutting corners in their power supply designs, which can impact the compatibility of traditional desktop (modified square wave output) UPSs with computer systems that use these new power supplies. For example, in some cases, the PFCs' "hold up" time is shorter, meaning UPSs, which normally would work fine with a computer, now do not transfer to battery power fast enough to keep the computer running during an outage. Active PFC power supplies can also draw excessively large inrush currents upon initial operation or during switches to battery power, overloading a UPS that would otherwise have been properly sized. Some active PFC power supplies work better when they receive pure sine wave power (Smart-UPS units), rather than the "modified sine wave" output of a Back-UPS unit, although, our testing shows that some active PFC power supplies don't care which type of output they receive.”
The problem is graphically represented at the CyberPower Systems Web site as a zero-output state occurring as a step-wave crosses from positive to negative voltage. While that zero-output state persists only for milliseconds, that’s still far longer than the instant that it occurs on a true sine wave. For most UPS manufacturers, the option is to upsell their customers a true-sine-wave model that costs far more to produce.
CyberPower’s solution appears to clip the peaks on a triangular wave, eliminating the zero-output state at lower cost than pure sine wave equipment. CyberPower calls this its “adaptive sine wave” technology, and one of our goals is to test its capabilities using a mid-priced, “enthusiast market,” active PFC power supply.
- Power Protection Or Rage Prevention?
- Why So Pricey?
- APC Smart-UPS SMT1500
- SMT1500 Management Software
- CyberPower CP1500PFCLCD
- CP1500PFCLCD Management Software
- Opti-UPS Durable Series DS1500B
- DS1500B Management Software
- Tripp Lite SmartPro SMART1500SLT
- SMART1500SLT Management Software
- Test Settings
- Benchmark Results